Sorry, I have to give dinner at Tony's thumbs down. I've described their food in the past like this, "If you can boil spaghetti and put some tomato paste on it and overcook steak, you can replicate a meal at Tony's."
I am Italian and grew up outside NYC, where all my relatives still lived. I've eaten a lifetime's worth of amazing, authentic Italian food, so I may be harder to please than most. That being said, this food isn't even passable in my book, just bad. The price made it even worse, but I wouldn't their dinner food for free.
Lunch, I have read more positive reviews for and may give that a try one day. Their breakfast used to be great! Enjoy!