shalom
DIS Veteran
- Joined
- Mar 7, 2010
- Messages
- 2,615
It is true that popular vacation destinations tend to be crowded. But what is now taking place at WDW is absurd and truly making the Disney experience a very unpleasant one.
This is not the universal opinion of those who've gone recently. I've read many positive reviews, here and elsewhere, by first timers and long timers, who have been to WDW since the old FP system was phased out. I have read many negative ones as well, obviously, but there's no way for any of us to know whether the "Disney experience" is worse or better now for the majority.
I am a repeat rider myself, and it sounds like some of my favorites are being negatively impacted by these changes. But that tells me nothing about whether it's improving things for the average park goer or not. And the fact is that Disney doesn't care about me any more than it does about any other individual -- their goal is to make the most people happy, not to make me, personally, happy. If my loss is three other people's gain, then that is what Disney's going to do. And Disney has a lot more data on whether that's what's happening or not than I do.
So what, exactly, was unfair about the old FP system that is not directly related to one's own choices about when to get to the parks and how often to use FP? What was there about the system itself that was unfair?
The new system is equally unfair in that people who make Rope Drop will still have the opportunity to ride more rides with less waiting. Someone on the Commando thread in the Community board reports that it looks like fewer people are making rope drop, presumably because people figure they've got those three FPs locked in so they don't have to rush, meaning the RD advantage is even greater under FP+.
One way that FP+ changes things is in allowing first timers more opportunity to ride the most popular rides. With FP-, people who were "in the know" because they'd been there before or because they'd done more research or because they were considerably more mobile could ride some rides multiple times with minimal waits, while first timers or the immobile were less able to get a fast pass and had longer waits because someone else was FPing for the third or fourth time that day.
People who used FP- to ride something multiple times still have the opportunity to ride multiple times; what they don't have is the opportunity to do it with only minutes of waiting. Now they have to pay the same "time costs" as first timers. All the people who always thought FP was unfair (I am not one of them) certainly think that part makes things "more fair."

People who were not as mobile were also at a disadvantage under FP-. I always made RD, and in terms of the gate could be at the front of the line, but in the race to FP machines I'd lose the advantage caused by "my own choice" to get there early, because other people could walk faster than I could. I definitely never chose to be short or stiff with sciatica.

Neither system was totally fair, and probably no system ever could be. If Disney continues to disallow repeat FPs, then it's pretty clear that Disney felt people using the FP system for multiple rides were disadvantaging the other riders. Disney's house, Disney's rules.


We were down to one gown this past year. And alas I think that's the end of it. Unless I engineer a switch to Halloween season. 