Disney now concedes

manning

Just for that I have requested it
Joined
Feb 12, 2002
Messages
13,353
Disney now concedes that well over 30% of its shareholders could wind up withholding their support from Mr. Eisner, the culmination of a brutal three- month campaign against Disney's chief of nearly two decades.


From

Dow Jones Business News dated 2/27/04


And they said it couldn't be done!
 
"I call on Disney directors to separate the positions of chairman and chief executive and to replace Mr. Eisner as soon as possible," New York Comptroller Alan Hevesi, the trustee for the nation's second-largest pension fund, said in a statement.

From reuters
 
Votes Against Eisner Could Top 30 Pct
5 minutes ago Add Business -


LOS ANGELES (Reuters) - The shareholder protest aimed at Walt Disney Co. Chief Executive Michael Eisner is expected to see more than 30 percent of shares cast at next week's annual meeting effectively opposing his re-election as chairman of the company's board, a Disney source said.


That show of discontent with Eisner's stewardship of the entertainment conglomerate would be much more widespread than first anticipated by analysts.


Disney would be inclined to see the result as a referendum on whether to separate the roles of chief executive and chairman, the source said. Roy Disney -- the nephew of company founder Walt Disney -- and Stanley Gold launched what was first seen as a long-shot campaign against Eisner and three other Disney directors after leaving the Disney board late last year.


Most analysts had initially assumed that Disney's improved results and rebounding share price would limit the impact of that campaign for major fund managers.


Disney shares have gained almost 90 percent since bottoming out in August 2002. The stock jumped earlier this month after Comcast Corp., the largest U.S. cable television operator, announced an unsolicited, all-stock bid for Disney that Eisner and the board rejected.


In the past two weeks, two proxy advisers, Institutional Shareholder Services and Glass Lewis, have recommended that investors withhold their votes for Eisner, effectively opposing his reappointment. A range of public pension funds including those representing California and New York have signaled that they would do so.


Eisner spent Thursday wooing fund managers for Ohio's public pension system, who were courted earlier in the week by Roy Disney.


Disney believes that the ISS recommendation, in particular, will carry weight with investors controlling 30 percent or more of its shares when the vote is tallied at its annual meeting, scheduled for March 3 in Philadelphia, a person familiar with the matter said.


The Wall Street Journal reported in its Friday edition that mutual fund company T. Rowe Price had also decided to vote in protest against Eisner by withholding its vote.


Some analysts have suggested that if the protest vote against Eisner, who like other Disney directors, is running unopposed, were to top 20 percent, that could force the hand of the company's board, already under intense pressure to demonstrate its independence.


One option urged by many analysts and ISS would be to split the roles of chairman and chief executive at Disney.


Another option would be for the company to detail a succession plan and perhaps even a timetable for the departure of Eisner, 61, who has led Disney since 1984 and whose contract expires in 2006.
 

No percentage automatically "loses him." I believe a 35% vote of "no confidence" means that a different slate of directors can be offered up for shareholders to vote on.

But it's not like, "35% of the stockholders voted against you, so you're fired", or anything like that.

A significant "no" vote simply means that additional slates of officers for the board must be considered and that other measures for independence -- seperating the roles of Chairman and CEO, for example -- must be developed.

:earsboy:
 
Analysts are coming out saying these fund announcements appear to be using Eisner to send a message regarding corporate governance in general.

They are taking advantage of the publicity opportunities and using the media to get a shot in against the problems plaguing the markets from the big CEO's of corporate past.

This trend is mounting growing criticism about motive on the Street.

Meanwhile, Disney's stock is trading below Comcast as we speak. The teeth are sharpening.
 
http://biz.yahoo.com/tsp/040227/10145911_1.html

RealCommentary from TheStreet.com
Eisner's Getting Backed Into a Corner
Friday February 27, 9:04 am ET

By James J. Cramer, RealMoney Columnist

Now we know some of what Brian Roberts knew when he commenced the Comcast (NasdaqNM:CMCSA - News) bid for Disney (NYSE:DIS - News ). We know that there are Disney board members who think the combination is intriguing (thanks to the diligent work of Rich Greenfield from Fulcrum, who is all over this one). We know that the hiring and firing of Michael Ovitz, a story now unsealed in Delaware, was a disgrace that even the comatose and totally-on-the-Michael-Eisner-payroll board members can recognize.

Most important, we know that even the most casual shareholders of the company, the pension folks -- let alone the diligent folks like Robert Genssler at T. Rowe Price -- can't stand Eisner. While people laughed at the amateur way that Roy Disney and Stanley Gold started their campaign, their campaign is proving far more effective than anyone dreamed.
 
The whole thing makes me believe that dreams do come true from Disney...when a Disney is in control....
 
The SEC is considering a rule change for 2005 where if there is at least 35 percent no votes against board members then share holders can nominate candidates. As it stands now only the board can nominate.
 
Not to much news, but here is a link:

http://story.news.yahoo.com/news?tm...=580&e=3&u=/nm/20040227/bs_nm/media_disney_dc

Vote Momentum Against Disney's Eisner

By Peter Henderson

LOS ANGELES (Reuters) - Another activist pension fund, North Carolina, on Friday joined at least seven states opposing Walt Disney Co. Chairman Michael Eisner's reelection to the board next week as Disney signaled it did not consider the vote a sweeping referendum on Eisner's stewardship.

Disney, braced for 30 percent of shareholders to oppose Eisner, also on Friday launched full-page advertisements in major newspapers featuring Mickey Mouse and Kermit the Frog and declaring "Our future is in good hands."

The 11-member Disney board is guaranteed to be reelected at the March 3 meeting, since there are no rival candidates, and so the battle is brewing whether to interpret a substantial percentage of votes withheld for Eisner as a call for him to step down or a less direct signal about corporate governance.

Comcast Corp. (Nasdaq:CMCSA - news) whose takeover bid was rejected by the Disney board, is also waiting in the wings in Philadelphia, coincidentally the city in which Disney's meeting will be held, and analysts said it could pounce again after the vote.

Nell Minow, a governance analyst at the Corporate Library, said the vote would send a message to Comcast and other potential buyers. "The higher the vote of no confidence, the more vulnerable the company is," she said.

Smith Barney analyst Niraj Gupta argued in a note that Comcast could resubmit its $48 billion bid or sweeten it slightly by adding or substituting a cash component to the all-stock offer.

"We believe that Comcast would cite the shareholder vote as evidence that a management change is in order," he wrote.

The Comcast offer is now worth about $3.20 per share less than Disney's shares are trading on the New York Stock Exchange (news - web sites), although the discount has narrowed from $3.60 in mid-February, when Disney rejected the bid. Comcast's all-stock offer represented a 10 percent premium when it was made.

State funds opposed to Eisner hold at least 40 million shares, about 2 percent of Disney stock, and many more are still making decisions.

In response to the move by the pension funds, Disney spokeswoman Zenia Mucha pointed to the company's "laser-focus on building shareholder value" and its forecast for double-digit growth in earnings through 2007.

"Disney management and the board believe the company has well laid out its key long-term strategies for achieving attractive double-digit earnings growth, which is reinforced by the strong recent performance of Disney shares," she said.

DISNEY SEES PROTEST OVER DUAL ROLES

A Disney source said that the company was prepared for more than 30 percent of shareholders to withhold their votes for Eisner and that the company saw the signal as a protest, largely inspired by adviser Institutional Shareholder Services, against his combined roles of chairman and chief executive.

Board member Judith Estrin made similar arguments in interviews with major newspapers. The board has not wavered from its public support of Eisner and his strategy for keeping Disney an independent content company focused on household names that range from Mickey Mouse to ESPN, and now include the Muppets after a recent acquisition.

Minow put the influence of ISS at around 10 percent of votes and said the board had wide latitude to interpret and respond to the results of the vote, including simply stepping up communication with investors.

A majority of the 11 board members up for reelection face protest votes or recommendations against them from two major shareholder advisers, major pension funds, or dissidents Roy Disney and Stanley Gold.

The board has reformed its governance rules over the past few years, although critics say Eisner still has too much power and that more reform is needed.

North Carolina Treasurer Richard Moore said on Friday that his state pension funds would withhold votes for Eisner as chief executive and chairman -- although he is only up for reelection to the board -- and withhold votes for the three audit committee members.

"As one of the most visible companies in the country Disney's management needs to be more responsive to its owners. The failure of the company to generate long-term value for shareholders combined with their past inattention to good corporate governance practices has forced us to take this step," he said in a statement.

Disney shares lost 20 cents or less than 1 percent to end at $26.53 on the New York Stock Exchange on Friday.
 
http://story.news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story2&u=/bw/20040227/bs_bw/b3873044&e=4

Get Mickey II: The Plot Thickens
[BusinessWeek Online]
Fri Feb 27, 4:18 PM ET

Don't count Comcast CEO Brian L. Roberts out just yet. Walt Disney Co. (NYSE: DIS - News ) may have slapped down Comcast Corp.'s (CMCSIC.) $54 billion hostile bid for the House of Mouse. And Comcast's stock may be off 11.3% since the Feb. 11 offer, even as Disney's share price has risen 8.6%. Sure, that shows little incentive for Comcast or Disney investors to do a deal. But while Roberts says he is prepared to "walk away," Comcast insiders say they've "had expressions" of support from Disney board members. Disney denies that, but Comcast also is banking on a growing campaign to vote against Michael D. Eisner's reelection at the Mar. 3 annual meeting. The movement got a big boost on Feb. 25, when the giant California Public Employees Retirement Systems said it would withhold its vote against Eisner.

The upshot: Or Comcast could raise its bid above the original offer, which valued Disney at $26.47 a share. Roberts & Co. are keenly aware that raising the bid could enrage Comcast shareholders, many of whom, just 15 months after Comcast's $54 billion purchase of AT&T Broadband, are against further dilution. Comcast execs also know that stock alone will not entice Disney shareholders. So any new bid would probably include a cash carrot.

How much higher is Roberts prepared to go? Analysts reckon Comcast could come back with an offer that values Disney at close to $30 a share, or $61 billion, excluding Disney's $12 billion in debt. That would give Disney shareholders about 50% of the combined company. But to further entice Disney shareholders, Comcast could enrich its $30 offer by making part of it cash -- to the tune of $3.50 or more per share, or about $7.5 billion, according to UBS Securities. Paying more could make sense, according to Merrill Lynch & Co. (MER.), since Comcast stands to boost its projected free cash flow in the first year from $2.2 billion to at least $3.2 billion.

What's more, Comcast can probably afford to raise the bid. In addition to its strong cash flow, the company has holdings in Liberty Media (NYSE:L - News), Time Warner (NYSE:TWX - News ), and other cable partnerships. If sold, those properties could garner $15 billion, estimates Merrill Lynch analyst Jessica Reif Cohen. "This is a company that can raise $10 billion and not hurt its credit rating," says UBS analyst Aryeh B. Bourkoff.

`SHOW US THE MONEY'. Still, upping the bid carries risks. It could infuriate Comcast shareholders, who have chafed each time the giant has neared profitability only to make another acquisition that dilutes their stakes. "It's time to show us the money," says Glenn Greenberg, managing director of Chieftain Capital Management Inc., which owns nearly 1% of Comcast, or 20 million shares. He wants Comcast to use its free cash flow to buy back stock. And if Comcast execs are unsuccessful, their credibility will take a hit, which could hamper their ability to do more deals.

Still, as his past string of deals shows, Roberts isn't easily deterred. Remember, Roberts upped his bid twice before winning AT&T Broadband. More important, Roberts is committed to the vision of marrying content -- movies, TV shows, and sports -- with Comcast's 22 million cable subscribers. Besides, Comcast may have little choice: By 2006, many analysts figure its subscriber growth could start to plateau, and margins from customers who added data and phone service will slide under competitive pressure from the phone companies.

Until it makes a move, Comcast is in what Merrill Lynch's Cohen calls "deal limbo." As a result, its stock is now trading at lower multiples than smaller counterparts such as Cox Communications Inc. (NYSE:COX - News) or Cablevision Systems Corp. (NYSE:CVC - News ). With all the uncertainty dragging its stock down, Comcast may feel pressure either to pull out or make another bid sooner rather than later. Disney's upcoming annual meeting in Philadelphia could tell the tale: A hefty "No" vote for Eisner could force the Disney directors to replace him, according to people close to the board. And that, combined with a sweetened offer from Roberts, could send Disney into the arms of Comcast.
 
At the same time if the board acts swiftly enough, picks the right person to take over and the stock price stages a strong recovery, then there could be a chance to remain independent. A loong shot, but could happen.

Anything could happen!!!
 








Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top Bottom