Yup... I hope there aren't any hard feelings about the tipping discussion. At least it won't matter for my December trip, as we're now on the dining plan and our servers will be getting 18% regardless. I only hope the service they provide is deserving of it.

I lucked out in that I happened to be browsing allears.net or the UG's website on the day they opened up the CP reservations. I called immediately and had a choice of three different times for my LeCellier ADR, all better than the original 4:40 non-CP reservation.
As to the general question of getting desirable ADR times at desirable restaurants... I think calling first thing at 7 AM on the 180 day mark provides a real advantage over those who call later that same day.
David