DCL carry-on alcohol policy changing Sept. 30 2015

The "each port of call" experience cruisers are recounting now is consistent with DCL historically. In ports of call, DCL either never allowed any guests to bring on alcohol or confiscated it until the end of the cruise. I was told that this was borne from both safety/customs issues with local authorities as well as the level of docking fees paid by DCL for that privilege.

I agree that the announcement could have been articulated better.

On all of our 14 DCL cruises, we have never had any liquor, etc. confiscated at any port of call (other than Grand Cayman), so I respectfully disagree that it is what DCL has historically done. The only port where we could not bring liquor back on board was Grand Cayman - something to do with customs at that particular port, and we were advised of that prior to disembarking there.
 
I just called. The first girl that answered said you are not allowed to restock at ports of call. I let her know that is not how the policy reads. I let her know what was happening on the Magic and she got supervisor Gabby and Gabby said you should be able to restock the beer wine and champagne and bring it to your room at ports of call. They will again clarify on Monday and find out why the Magic did not let them bring it to their rooms. I should be getting a call Monday. They said I was the first call about it.
 

The "each port of call" experience cruisers are recounting now is consistent with DCL historically. In ports of call, DCL either never allowed any guests to bring on alcohol or confiscated it until the end of the cruise. I was told that this was borne from both safety/customs issues with local authorities as well as the level of docking fees paid by DCL for that privilege.

I agree that the announcement could have been articulated better.
Not so. We just brought beer on in Maui. You've always been able to bring alcohol on at ports of call.
 
They just don't know what they are doing. Eventually it is going to be a no alcohol brought on policy. My issue is nibody working at the call center or onboard knows what is going on. Train your staff!

And to those that do not see this as a big deal wait until they charge for soda or other items, then it will be a big deal.
 
I just called. The first girl that answered said you are not allowed to restock at ports of call. I let her know that is not how the policy reads. I let her know what was happening on the Magic and she got supervisor Gabby and Gabby said you should be able to restock the beer wine and champagne and bring it to your room at ports of call. They will again clarify on Monday and find out why the Magic did not let them bring it to their rooms. I should be getting a call Monday. They said I was the first call about it.
I also just called. The original castmember I spoke to (Shaylee) said you are not allowed to bring alcohol on board in a port, and when I also read over the policy she got her supervisor, who also got my phone number and said they would "get back to me with clarification," so it sounds like they truly do not know what the policy is. Shaylee also told meg though, that it was the amount of beer/wine brought on board per adult passenger, the way it is packed didn't matter. As lone as it is in a carry-on, two or more adults can pack it together. I don't know whether to take this as truth or not the way things have been going with these policies!
 
The "each port of call" experience cruisers are recounting now is consistent with DCL historically. In ports of call, DCL either never allowed any guests to bring on alcohol or confiscated it until the end of the cruise. I was told that this was borne from both safety/customs issues with local authorities as well as the level of docking fees paid by DCL for that privilege.

I agree that the announcement could have been articulated better.
On the WBPC in May we were running low on Kahlua in our stateroom. Bought a big bottle at a duty free at the port in Cartagena. Was pretty miffed that I pay double or more in the states. Anywhoo, carried it on & consumed most of it over te rest of the cruise. So I can testify from experience that spirits were previously allowed onboard at ports to take back to your stateroom for consumption. Additionally, in Cartagena I bought myself a bottle of coffee wine. I also carried it onboard, placed in my stateroom, but did not consume it. I could have. I brought it home instead. That bottle is in my cabinet waiting for my next visit with my momma. :)
 
The "each port of call" experience cruisers are recounting now is consistent with DCL historically. In ports of call, DCL either never allowed any guests to bring on alcohol or confiscated it until the end of the cruise. I was told that this was borne from both safety/customs issues with local authorities as well as the level of docking fees paid by DCL for that privilege.

I agree that the announcement could have been articulated better.

Nope, definitely not the case before the policy change. We bought Vanilla and Mango Rum in Nassau and the Vanilla Rum never made it home. It was so good that we finished it during the rest of the cruise ;). No alcohol that we have ever bought in port has been taken. We have always just brought it back to the room with us.

I have also heard about the problems on the Magic since they implemented the new policy and I am curious to see how this plays out. We didn't plan on purchasing anything in port on our next cruise because we don't drink beer or wine usually anyway. But now I might pick up a bottle of wine just to see what happens, LOL.
 
I watched a couple of cruisers bring 2 cases of beer on board at st. Thomas just 2 weeks ago. We were on the 9/12 fantasy cruise.
 
Nope, definitely not the case before the policy change. We bought Vanilla and Mango Rum in Nassau and the Vanilla Rum never made it home. It was so good that we finished it during the rest of the cruise ;). No alcohol that we have ever bought in port has been taken. We have always just brought it back to the room with us.

I have also heard about the problems on the Magic since they implemented the new policy and I am curious to see how this plays out. We didn't plan on purchasing anything in port on our next cruise because we don't drink beer or wine usually anyway. But now I might pick up a bottle of wine just to see what happens, LOL.

Our next cruises are a B2B on the Dream in January. I was thinking about experimenting with buying some rum in Nassau on the first cruise and seeing if I would have it available foe the second leg of the cruise. Normally I'm mostly a wine drinker, but want to do this as an experiment to see how the new policy works.
 
I watched a couple of cruisers bring 2 cases of beer on board at st. Thomas just 2 weeks ago. We were on the 9/12 fantasy cruise.

The alcohol policy was hot implemented then. The new one just started on the 30th.

I called and a supervisor did call me back. She said she felt their is miscommunication on the Magic but would not clarify the policy until their executive meeting in Monday. She will call me late Monday or Tuesday.
 
Our next cruises are a B2B on the Dream in January. I was thinking about experimenting with buying some rum in Nassau on the first cruise and seeing if I would have it available foe the second leg of the cruise. Normally I'm mostly a wine drinker, but want to do this as an experiment to see how the new policy works.
I was thinking about doing this with their own duty free shop and see what happens. it should be dropped off at the end of the first cruise. it will not matter either way because its not for me but could be interesting.
 
I know this has been kind of beat to death on this and other threads but it wasn't the limits on alcohol as much as how they implemented the change. For many of us, it came after our PIF date, so we had booked and paid for the cruise under one policy and now, with no way to cancel, are forced to adhere to a more restricted policy.

DH and I don't drink beer or wine usually so it leaves us with no options other than to buy on the ship (and we can't even order a bottle of our preferred beverage to drink in our room because you can only order beer and wine packages).

Then when people tried to express their displeasure to DCL, everyone either received canned responses or no response at all. DCL really just snubbed everyone that had an issue with how the policy was presented. Comments on facebook were deleted as soon as they were posted, etc. That is why many people have said that this may be their last Disney cruise. Who knows what the next change will be. It is industry standard to charge for the kids clubs in the evenings on most cruise lines. Maybe without warning they will start charging for the Oceaneers Club and Lab. I'm betting that some of those people that didn't understand why we were upset about the alcohol policy change will understand once they have to change their budget at the last minute to start paying for the clubs (or some other benefit that is included now).

I agree. I believe that DCL will begin charging for this within the next year.
 
I agree. I believe that DCL will begin charging for this within the next year.
If they did, they would then have to lower their cruise prices, as it is one of the things that allows them to justify the higher prices than other lines. So, I really don't see this happening.
 
If they did, they would then have to lower their cruise prices, as it is one of the things that allows them to justify the higher prices than other lines. So, I really don't see this happening.
there have been a lot of things that allows them to justify the higher prices that have been taken away, such as what this thread is about, but they have not lowered their prices yet. they never will. I to feel that the cost of pop will eventually have a charge. I also don't doubt for a minute that eventually the clubs will have fees after certain hours. like any business they will push until they get pushed back. its business and they want to make $$.
 
If they did, they would then have to lower their cruise prices, as it is one of the things that allows them to justify the higher prices than other lines. So, I really don't see this happening.
Well, my justification for higher prices was their BYOB drink policy and the fact that the didn't charge for soft drinks. Everybody has their own justifications and Disney has taken some away already, so why would that stop them? By the way, this change was enough for me to cancel our two placeholders and book a cruise next year on Royal where we will buy their drink package and still come out ahead on $.
 
From DCL site

"Please note that the Disney Cruise Line alcohol policy is subject to change without notice."

They just spent two months explaining the policy over and over to people. Saying that you could replenish. So the first cruise out they change their minds?

The alcohol policy was hot implemented then. The new one just started on the 30th.

But the comment was about Disney not allowing alcohol to be brought onboard at other ports. Has nothing to do with current policy but what the poster said about the past.


If they are saying that the policy reads that you can bring it on but have it confiscated, they have to understand that it reads that you can bring it on in the embarkation port the same way...so you might have it confiscated in PC!

We're their lawyers all on vacation when the new policy was written?
 

GET UP TO A $1000 SHIPBOARD CREDIT AND AN EXCLUSIVE GIFT!

If you make your Disney Cruise Line reservation with Dreams Unlimited Travel you’ll receive these incredible shipboard credits to spend on your cruise!






















New Posts







DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top