The biggest selling point for VGF direct - if you sell it 7-10 years down the road, you're likely to recover most/all of your upfront cost. If you buy Poly2 direct, you'll likely lose 50%+ due to the resale restrictions. If you add that anticipated capital loss of $12-$15/point a year as part of your vacation cost, it's much hard to justify the direct purchase (think $20-$25/point dues all in - you're just better off renting). Of course, if you keep it for 50 years, it doesn't matter at all...
Personally, I would never buy a resale-restricted resort direct. The more restrictions they place, the more they hurt the resale value of what they sold me. I may buy it on the resale market, once the price settled at a point that reflects its lack of ability to trade at any other resort internally (which to me, is sub $100). Otherwise, I'll just stay at that resort by booking at 7 months out with my VGF direct points

.