I'm also curious. we have been in casitas 5, casitas 3 and cabanas 8.
casitas 5 was ok, kind of in the middle between the main pool and el centro. 3 was just gorgeous! 3rd floor, facint the lagoon, but kinda a long walk to the maya pool, but close to el centro.
the cabanas are by far the most convenient to everything, but we find the temem very "blah". we were 1st floor , facing the quiet pool, steps away from it. a few minutes to our car, , so close to everything, but just kinda blah.
hubby always LVOES the look of the ranchos quiet pool. I'm not crazy about the "rocky", NON'plush theme. but it
's the distance to el centro that concerns me.. esp. because of refilling the mugs. the mug refill at maya pool closes so early!