Personally I loved both of them. It is really a preference of characters. 1900 PF has alice, the mad hatter, mary poppins, and tigger. CP has pooh, tigger, piglet, and eeyore. The character interaction was great at both, although if you are celebrating a birthday at 1900, (im not sure they still do this, but i think so), they have the little one stand up and eveyone sings happy birthday to them. I thought that was really special. I was celebrating mine, and even though im not a kid, i still received a tiara, and a cupcake with a candle in it. It was really special. Hope this helps!