psac
DIS Veteran
- Joined
- Jan 2, 2009
- Messages
- 3,237
I agree! Well, at least our family is divided on this issue, and my opinion is based on the purpose of our stay. I LOVE a boardwalk view. I love the sounds, the music, the activity, and even the honking Friendship Boats. Also, we've been able to see the MK fireworks in the distance from our boardwalk view rooms. We've requested a boardwalk view for all of our BWI CL stays, and I'm likely to request one again for January.
My husband, on the other hand, far prefers the garden view. For him, it's less Disney, more quiet and away from busy. As much as I love a boardwalk view, I appreciate these aspects of the garden view and the ability to watch and hear Illuminations from our room. I also now understand that our room assignment in February (no boardwalk view available, but they assigned us to a garden view 2-bedroom suite) could not have been more perfect for the nights leading up to the Princess Half Marathon.
All in all, I'll still take the boardwalk view, and I'll even risk it for the night before the full marathon in January!
A few photos of a garden view
I think I've seen all those pics before, but that doesn't make me like them any less. Especially the wine glass one, though remember for next time I prefer white.

I'm with your husband and Kook on the noise (and my wife maybe a little more so), but I'm with you on the view being worth it. Our first trip on the Inn side we were in the Deluxe club room and the extra hump really provided enough area to keep the sound away from the main sleeping area. On the Villa side for our stays now, we do sometimes put the bathroom light on for the fan white noise if it's still noisy when we go to sleep. For us it's worth it to have that BW view for the stay!
We keep saying we'll try a non-BW view one time to see if the noise is better, but then come the 11 month window, we're like nahhh, Are you kidding? BW view it is!
when I'm trying to get to sleep.

. I remember that wine glass fondly and I hope it was Merlot
. Have you thought about separate rooms for you and DH?

. Now we are staying 10 days in Disney! Yippee!!