Choose my dinner entree at Tony's Town Square

[Lil ole moi]

I'm undecided at which entree I should order at Tony's Town Square. There are 2 items in particular on the menu that appeal to me. For those that have been there, which should I order:

 

[whits_end]

Honestly, I'd say neither! I had the lamb shank with polenta when I was there. Normally I am addicted to Italian food, but I had heard a couple of people around us and our server rave about it, so I tried it. It was amazing!!! My husband has been trying to recreate the polenta for me ever since. One of the best meals I had on our last trip.

 

[rznhal]

I've never had the spaghetti, but the chicken parmigiana was very good! Enjoy!!

 

[darlak]

The spaghetti is just okay, but if you like steak, the New York Strip is wonderful.
I've never tried the chicken parmigiana.

 

[jlk806]

The chicken parm is awesome and it comes with spaghetti. I had that last year and loved it!

 

[grace&philipsmom]

I enjoyed the chicken parm, but my favorite thing on the menu was the pistachio creme brulee - delish!

 

[sbprincess]

I haven't had the spaghetti but I thought the chicken parm was gross. They over cooked the noodles by a lot. I like my pasta right at or slightly past al dente. Tony's were almost mush. Then the sauce wasn't what I like either. The actual chicken breast was great though! So seeing as the spaghetti and sauce were what I did NOT like about the chicken parm, I really can't recommend either.

We did have lunch there in 2008 and the flatbread was great. If I ever go back (which I'm not rushing to do any time soon), I will probably do lunch again for the flatbread.

Oh, and the "tiramisu" was more like tiramisu flavored pudding when we got it. No ladyfingers in either of our portions. Maybe it was just that we got the last of a tray or something. I was disappointed though. FYI

 

[nicole0992]

I picked the chicken parm. I have had it numerous times and the chicken is always good. The spahetti has been overcooked on my dish though.