We ate there for dinner in Dec. This was one of our best meals. We highly enjoyed it. I agree CM does get mixed reviews. I think everyone is different and you have to make up your own mind.
Some of the food we had was: peel and eat shrimp, pork loin with wild mushroom sauce (I didn't care for this, it was cooked with a wine which I didn't like), baked chicken, baked fish, parmesan potatoes (yummy), & ravioli with alfredo sauce (yummy). Kids had: chicken tenders, pizza, mac & cheese. Desserts were: chocolate mousse, key lime tart, fruit cheesecake, sundae bar, cookies, sugarfree brownies and fruit. This will definately be a place that we revisit.