@
ewalshslp
Hmm, very strange indeed, and frustating, I'm sure! Well, this may sound silly or obvious but be sure you are looking at the flight times for the right airport you want to fly out of. I have done this several times, and almost totally booked the wrong flights - Instead of going from Chicago MDW to Orlando MCO, I had it reversed and was looking at going from Orlando MCO to Chicago MDW on the dates I needed and those times were totally different with times and prices! I was getting very confused, and pretty happy with one of those cause the prices were definitely better, but finally realized I'd been looking going the wrong ways.
I know you probably have checked that, but just in the tiny chance it might help, I figured I'd post my experience.
And if all else fails, you can call and they can help you rebook the flights you want to change to. I had to have them help me recently and it went very smoothly. Supposedly, if you then find another flight reduction you want to switch to, you then have to call again and they can help you again no problem, but you'd have to call to switch, but can do it as needed. And you can do this anytime day or night. The few times I've called for help with this, it was usually between 3 - 5 a.m.
How did you book, credit card or points?