We've done both, and I far preferred CBR! It has that tropical feel, nice light colors, beautiful beaches, and the rooms are just as big as those in the WL, but because of furniture size and color of the rooms, those at CBR seem much bigger. I was very disappointed with the rooms and decor at the WL. I guess I am not into dark masculine motifs.
Also, the scent in the lobby at the WL (a mixture of the smokehouse and pine) bothered my sinuses. I did like the archetecture of the lobby, and the pool, though!
Also, we found the transporation from the WL to be poor.
For my money, the CBR was a more enjoyable place to stay.