Just back from our first ever stay at CBR (10/25-10/30). I will post some pix later, but here is my initial review....
First, I must say that this thread was HUGE help in getting me ready to fully enjoy this wonderful resort. Thanks to ALL who contribute info great and small; it all adds up.
We traveled on 10/24 and spent that night at the LBV Comfort Inn (very nice place for $42, I might add). We arrived at CBR around 9AM on 10/25 to check in. Our room (Trinidad North 3153) was ready immediately!

. What a wonderful bonus it was to be able to go ahead and put our stuff in the room and take in the aura of the place before we headed off to the parks for the day. We were immediately impressed with the orderliness and cleanliness of the resort, especially our room. Any doubts about the room being less than clean or needing some TLC were dispelled quickly. We put away our things and made the short walk to the main pool area and OPR.
The kids were excited about the themed pool, and eager to schedule a swim for later in the day

. We strolled thru the Straw Market and Calypso marketplace, taking time to examine all the pirate goodies.
Positives:
1) The feeling of being "on island". Wonderfully themed resort!
2) Variety of flora. For example, there was this beautiful yellow flowering tree right at the corner of the stairwell nearest the main walkway in building 31 that I came to call "my tree" because i wanted to take it home with me

. I'll have to search and see if I took a pic of it or not. Many other flowers, trees, and bushes that delighted DW and I very much
3) Sitting on the beach between OPR and Trinidad North and watching Illuminations. (We did this three times)
4) Service at the food court was always good. We never ran into an unreasonably long line.
5) The main pool was fun every time -and we used it every day. Never did try the quiet pools.
6) The bus service was good for the most part (see below)
7) Cleanliness of the whole resort -room and common areas. (one teeny exception)
"Negatives":
1) It once took us 55 minutes to get to MK AFTER being picked up at the bus stop. To be fair, the bus did have to stop and pick up two guests in wheelchairs. This accounted for much of the time. I don't begrudge the folks in wheelchairs/scooters one iota; I just wish Disney could figure a way to get everyone transported safely and more quickly in such circumstances.
2) The blue cabinet that housed the refrigerator in the room had large chunks/chips of paint missing from it. Not that I cared a whole lot, but it was kind of incongruous with the immaculate state of rest of the room.
3) I can't get channel 96 on my DirecTV here at home

. I fell in love with that channel
4) On at least three different days we did not receive mousekeeping service until after 2PM. This was a tad inconvenient since this was around the time each of those days that we were taking a break from the parks. On at least a couple of those days DW had wanted to stay in the room and read/relax while I took the kids to the pool. She wound up having to come along and read poolside. Again... no biggie, but would have been nice to have come back midafternoon to a clean room.
Any questions?