Right, but that's what I was trying to say wasn't the case. It's not hurting them. They're getting something for free.
The net effect of having a random set of people getting this for free, is that those that have paid for it, get hurt. This levels the playing field.
While some can interpret cutting the ADR short to 45 is hurting those that get
free dining....it's not, it's protecting those that pay for it.
regardless, I doubt disney would do it anyway, because there will always be someone who views it as a punishment, and disney would likely not want to deal with the collateral that comes with explaining it away...