soniam
Wooden leg named Smith...
- Joined
- Jun 22, 2012
- Messages
- 14,217
That's an interesting thought about Hong Kong..hadn't really thought about it that way and now that you mention it that does make sense. You're right about Tokyo for sure.
As for distance I was more or less comparing the distance between each location to the other location not really the size of the country where the parks were built. I checked the distance before posting and it's about a 2 hour flight between Shanghai and Hong Kong. It's around a 4 hour flight from Toyko Disneyland to Hong Kong Disneyland if you take a non-stop flight or if you go from Toyko to Shanghai it's around a 2 hours and 40 minutes flight if you take a non-stop flight.
However, it's a 5 1/2 hour flight from DLR to WDW therefore meaning that all three of the above listed destinations are actually closer to each other in distance than DLR and WDW. Also if you consider taking a train between Hong Kong and Shanghai it's less time than traveling by car between DLR and WDW.
Demographics of each location plays a very large role in the location as rteez helped explain to me and maybe citizens of each area are less likely to travel outside that area that they are in (speculation cuz I really have no idea travel statistics of that region).
I just see it as Disney was more or less looking to expand unnecessarily at the time (IMO) to Shanghai (though not suprising at all where more more more locations becomes the mantra) when they could have injected that money into expanding/upgrading/improving their already existing parks both domestically and internationally which would have allowed a greater control over the finances with the everchanging economy.
Well from what I understand Hong Kong is very different demographically and culturally (due to its history) to Shanghai. There may not be much overlap between those two.
I don't know much of anything about Chinese internal travel patterns, but it's certainly the case that not every country hops on and off planes like people in the US do and I have read that train and bus travel is more common in China. Which would substantially increase the travel time.
I wonder if it's not just the way people travel, but if it's partly are they able/allowed to travel. I don't know, since I am not from China and have not lived there. However, Hong Kong has kind of been run separately, I thought, so maybe the government doesn't really allow mainlanders to travel to HK indiscriminately. Japan may really be out of the question in that case. Also, Japan may require Visas for Chinese nationals, which could be hard to come by. Being Americans, we don't always think about how many hoops others have to go through to travel. It's so easy for us compared to many. There's also just the cost of travel. I suspect more mainland Chinese could, maybe not now, afford to go to Shanghai but not HK or Tokyo.