When we first moved into our house (10 years ago) we had builder's grade vinyl and carpet downstairs. We quickly replaced the vinyl and carpet in the kitchen and famly room (one big room) with laminate that we bought at Sam's. It went in easiily and was pretty easy to install (did it ourselves). We were happy enough with it at first that we, about 1 year later, installed the same flooring in the Dining and Living Rooms.
A few years ago we had a minor leak under our kitchen sink (connection from sink filter blew) and with it only leaking for 10 mins. we got enough water on the family/kitchen floor that it was ruined. Our insurance carrier figured replacement of all of our downstairs floor since we wouldn't be able to match it. By this time we were no longer enamoured of our laminate. It was actually a fairly high maintenance floor. All spots showed and you had to constantly dust it. If it was a darker floor, it would have been even worse.
So we were ready for a change. About a year before my DSis and her DH put tile in their house. We liked the look of it and we decided to replace our floor with tile. It took us awhile to chose our tile but we ended up chosing the same tile as my DSis, but in a different color. Ours is browner than hers. Our tile is more dirt color, which is great!
We used Dal-Tile which we had to special order from Home Depot. It was only $1.79 p.s.f. which is a great place for domestic tile. We installed it ourselves so we saved on labor. We laid it in the kitchen , family room, laundy room and downstairs bath. We left the living room and dining room to be carpeted. (we were able to find enough of a remnant for these 2 rooms.) I believe we laid about 1000 or so sq. ft. of tile. With tile, mortar and grout, it costs us around $2500, or less.
We absolutely love having tile. And I never thought I would. It looks great most of the time and since we chose the color and pattern we did, it barely shows dirt. So much easier to take care of than the laminate.
Here's a picture of our tile in our entry, next to the Dining Room carpet.
The carpet is less gray in person than in this photo.
Tile is not as daunting as it seems. However, if you have wood underlayment you will have additional expense-you'll need cement board.
I believe our tile is procelain. We used 12" and 18" square tiles. I loved laying the larger tiles. Took so much less time.