Megan,
Just remember to each his own.....
We bought at SSR sight unseen in 2003. When we first stayed in May 2004 (right as it opened), I think only Congress Park area and maybe one other spot was open. Heavy construction etc... We liked the resort, but obviously the construction (temporary of course) made it hard to imagine the end result. Now, we love the grounds, it is gorgeous. I think because of the understated theme, a lot of people find that it lacks something, but I like it that way. And knowing Saratoga (we live in Saratoga NY) - they did an excellent and subtle job of capturing a lot of Saratoga (art, and little things). It wont slap you in the face like AKV or VWL, but I love the understated feel of the place.
Moving forward, SSR is probably the DVC Resort that takes the biggest hits in posts on the forum.
But - for us, we have no regrets. We love SSR, but also have used the DVC membership to stay at other resorts (OKW, BWV, AKV) and have enjoyed each resort for what it has to offer.
BLT is a great location, and I am sure will be up to the standards you expect from WDW and DVC. Just remember you have other options - although you can always book at the 11 month window to ensure your vacation spot - you have the 7 month window which for us has always been successful to try the different resorts.
Our DD fell in love with AKV, so this will be our second trip there. We have not been to SSR since 2006, but that does not mean we dont like the resort, we think it is great, just looking to try the others.
I hope you like BLT, but remember, you have many other places open to you, I am sure it will work out fine. If you bought into DVC because you love WDW, you will be fine
