This is a fun thread to read thru - glad it was bumped up.
It is neat to see all the different opinions of what people like and what people think is a waste of time

Goes to show, that cruises need to have a little bit of everything to try to appeal to everyone.
I liked Fish Extenders...once, after that it just became a hassle - too much to pack and plan, plus schedule a time to deliver gifts and then felt wasteful at the end of our cruise by throwing our most of the stuff we got.
Have never done Palo or Remy, but this thread has convinced me it is not worth it - I am just not a fancy person, and enjoy a hamburger and fries for dinner off the kids menu so I don't think those restaurants are for us - even though we will get a free Palo soon as Platinum members - so I am sure we will try it at least.
I don't like pirates in general, so I tend to avoid most things pirate-related that night anyway, but do like the fireworks.
The shows are always a must-do for us, even though as people have said - Villain's tonight and the retired-Toy Story were our least favorites and skippable.
We hate the comedians/magician - that would probably be our biggest waste of time - hate those nights on the cruise because it means there is no musical show. I would rather eat aluminum foil than watch a comedian or magician perform, but that is just me. I know some people look forward to those nights as they provide variety on the cruise which is great! I use those nights to go to Skyline or the adult bars on this ships and just relax.