Too funny - I usually end up getting the All-American without ranch too I've had the Chicken Florentine, which I also thought was good. The tuna melt and cannonballs were okay, but I like the others better. The scudetto was good, and I usually don't like those types of meat. I felt like the caprese was missing balsamic vinegar. I think I've had an original before, but I don't really remember it - guess that's probably not a selling point! I've not had the new grilled cheese or the beef 'n' bleu as I don't do bleu cheeses. The Ceasar salad is really good - their croutons are excellent and are clearly made from the bread. I know a lot of people who like the Chinese chicken salad and the tomato soup, although I haven't tried either of those. The chocolate chip cookies are excellent, and I'm very picky when it comes to my cookies! One other thing I'll do sometimes is get the kids' grilled cheese and then get a side salad with Ceasar dressing. If you ask nicely, they'll usually put on some croutons and cheese too