Bad experience with Thrifty--a warning!

Took

DIS Veteran
Joined
Aug 22, 1999
Messages
1,955
For the first time in our many years of traveling to Disney, we rented from Thrifty. Previously, we had rented from National and Budget (both on site) and had experienced no problems. But I got budget-minded this trip and saw that Thrifty's rental rates were much lower than anyone else's. I thought, "What's a little shuttle ride?" I regret my decision.

Our experience in renting a mid-size car from Thrifty was so-so. Essentially, you get what you pay for. Our car was dinged up and not as clean as others I've rented, but for the price, it was OK. However one thing made the rental a near-disaster right off : Ruben, the sales agent, a fast-talker if there ever was one.

First, when we walked up, Ruben started off by rapidly and in what I think of as high-pressure sales manner, trying to get us to buy a larger, more expensive car. He didn't really "ask" us if we wanted to upgrade so much as insinuate that we SHOULD upgrade, and he lined up the prices for upgrade rapidly in a row ($12.99 for this, 25.99 for this...meaning, per day!) What's more, if we had accepted Ruben's "generous" offers, we would have paid quite a bit more for renting a larger car than if I had originally reserved the larger car in the first place. THe upgrade rates were ridiculous in comparison! We refused politely.

Then, 'Ruben' moved to exploit the customer tactic two: he did not ask us if we wanted "insurance" per se (which we did not), but instead, quickly (very quickly) worked the phrase "basic coverage" into the description of what we were purchasing. Thinking a "basic" rental meant "no coverage" we said OK. After he had printed up the receipt for our rental, I noticed the total was more than double the amount I expected to pay and I asked him to explain. He said "It includes such-and-such for the rental, such-and-such for the taxes and 'basic coverage', and then I figured out he was talking about insurance. I explained I did not need insurance and he, denfensively, responded "I asked if you wanted basic coverage!" To avoid arguing, I agreed that he had asked and said I had made the mistake and to please remove the insurance, which he did with somewhat poorly concealed irritation. It was a grim moment and completely disconcerted me (we had been up since 4:00am).

After that, everything was OK, but my experience with Ruben nearly ruined my day. I admit, I had been warned about high-pressure sales from Thrifty agents and hoped to find these warnings without foundation. Unfortunately, that wasn't the case. Right now, I can't imagine going back to Thrifty, not for any amount of savings! No one wants to start off his or her vacation with "negative vibes."

For those who choose to go with Thrifty anyway, please beware--Ruben was "lead sales agent" and, from our point of view, he got that way by bullying and conning customers into paying for what they didn't need!
 
Yikes!
I've had a certain agent at Alamo try the "Basic Coverage" scam on me twice (it's the woman who works around midnight on Friday nights...I've never had a problem any other time). We've only rented from Thrifty once, and they didn't pull anything like that. We're renting from them again, so I'll be sure to post if that has changed. Hopefully it's just the one agent, although as you say, if it's a Lead, that's pretty bad!
Barb
Visit the Platinum Castaway Club at: www.castawayclub.com
 
That's what I love about about National's Emerald Aisle. The only question I have to answer at the exit booth is if I want the fuel option (no). No pressure for insurance or anything else.
 
I haven't used Thrifty in years primarily for the reasons that you mention. My Brother in law used them last year and had a similar experience with the upgrade sales and insurance pressure. That is why I love National's Emerald Club. All your preferences are set up in your profile and if you select no insurance (which I do) no one pressures you to get it or upgrade. You walk out to your car class, get in the car of your choice and drive away. (After checking out at the booth of course. ;) )
 

We did our Thrifty rental last night, so here's an update:
We just missed the bus when we arrived at the airport, so I called to make sure another one was coming. I needn't have bothered, as two more pulled up literally within two minutes.
At the counter, there was a line but lots of counter people so it only took a few minutes before we were served. There was no pressure to purchase an upgrade, even though we had the cheapest kind of car, but they were definitely more hard-sell about the insurance this time. I wonder if they are having some kind of push for sales or a commission bonus, as they weren't this bad list time. I told the counter agent I know the details and don't need to hear about it, but he insisted on doing his spiel anyway. I don't like being treated like a child, but oh well...I can put up with it for the good rate :D It's been just as bad at other car rental agencies, although I've noticed they usually don't push it as hard when I rent from Priceline...maybe because it's prepaid and they figure I'm a cheapskate.
Anyway, we are going to join Thrifty's Blue Chip, which eliminates all that nonsense. But I would recommend them for rentals...just be prepared to say "No, no, no" and check your paperwork (they didn't try to slip anything in on me).
By the way, the car was a Kia in good shape, with 1000 miles on it.
Barb
Visit the Platinum Castaway Club at: www.castawayclub.com
 
Thought I'd offer an update. I wrote to Thrifty about my problems with Ruben last week, after they sent me an email asking about my experience as a renter. They indicated that they'd reply in 24-48 hours, but haven't yet, either b/c of the holidays or b/c....?

Will let you all know what I hear.

Took
 
/
I promised an update on our experiences with Thrifty and thought I'd pass on my response from their customer service dept, whom I emailed about our run in with "Ruben."

At any rate, here's the reply:


"Thank you for notifying us of your recent experience with Thrifty Car Rental
in Orlando. On behalf of Thrifty Car Rental, please accept our sincere
apologies for any inconvenience you experienced.

Thrifty Car Rental makes every effort to disclose all necessary information
applicable to the rental. This is especially true of driving restrictions,
optional coverage items, airport fees, credit card restrictions, and any
state surcharges. Our Rental Sales Agents receive extensive training to
ensure that policies and restrictions are disclosed to the customer on every
transactions. In an effort to maintain consistency and standardization of
this policy, our agents also receive regular, recurrent training and a sales
training team randomly monitors their rental transactions during actual
rentals.

At Thrifty Car Rental, we strive to provide quality products and services;
this includes serviceable vehicles and friendly, efficient service. We
sincerely regret your reported dissatisfaction and have forwarded your
comments to the manager of this location so that the necessary corrective
measures can be taken.

We appreciate your business and hope you will allow us another opportunity
to fulfill your car rental needs in the efficient, professional manner you
expect and deserve.
If you could please email me back with your mailing address so I can send
you out a $50.00 coupon for a future rental. If you have any further
questions or comments please feel free to contact me.

Thank you once again, Mr. Roehrs, for taking the time to notify us of this
situation. We look forward to serving you again soon at Thrifty Car Rental."


That's the whole story, folks. They did send me a $50 coupon, which I don't believe I'll ever use. I don't think I could face the hassle again, but, I suppose, it was nice of them to offer. My final advice, use Thrifty at your own risk and stay "heads up."

Took
 
Thanks for the update!
We just joined Blue Chip because I suspect we will be using Thrifty for quickie weekend trips when we don't get something through Priceline. It makes me feel better to know that if we have a bad experience, they will do something about it.
We won't have to deal with the insurance BS anymore because of Blue Chip. So far so good on the cars...on the last trip, they upgraded us and gave us a totally loaded Ford Focus with less than 300 miles on it. Hopefully they'll keep up the good work for us, although I know what a difference certain agents can make. There is a woman who works the Alamo counter on Fridays when our usual flight comes in, and I cringe every time I see her. I sure wish Alamo would send a survey!
Barb
Visit the Platinum Castaway Club at: www.castawayclub.com
 














Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top