I am newly engaged (Christmas morning!!!) and am now terrified of planning my reception. I am not sure how much things cost for catering, but I feel like I will be ridiculed if I don't do a top notch dinner now. I didn't realize people had such strong feelings about what is to be served at the reception. I would like an afternoon wedding (about 1:00) and the reception to follow. I was planning on appetizers, but may need to rethink!!!
If you don't want complaints, you might rethink the time. 1:00 is still a little close to lunchtime; 2PM with reception to follow would indicate (to me) that no full meal is planned, as the reception would probaby be winding down by 5PM, and most evening meals of this sort are not served until 6 or later.
I had a 6PM wedding, so I automatically planned for a sitdown dinner, bar, and dancing. The reception was FOLLOWED by "appetizers" etc at my parent's house, as this was the tradition in our area, and preceeded by a luncheon at my house, along with a formal rehersal dinner the night before. The party post reception party broke up at around 2AM, or so I heard. The happy couple are NOT usually invited, as they are supposed to be off starting their honeymoon.
Now, most of my Roman Catholic friends had a high nuptual mass at 11AM, which meant that in addition to the bridesmaid luncheon the day before, rehearsal dinner the night before, and a prewedding "young female only or male only guests/wedding party" celebration after the rehearsal dinner (which DH & I also had, separately) a wedding breakfast was included, along with a sitdown lunch, bar, dancing, etc, plus a party at the bride's parents house afterwards. If I was a bridesmaid, it meant a full weekend of activities.
Families would start saving for weddings as soon as the child was born, or go into debt to pay for it. I hope DD would rather have punch and cookies than have us do that. (Not that that will happen; see the first part of the previous sentence. I opened the wedding accounts and college accounts at the same time.)
So, yes, I might be surprised by a reception that just had a few finger sandwiches, wedding cake, and fruit punch. BUT, I would never say anything, and would stop to eat on the way home. As this only happened once after I moved south 25 years ago, it hasn't been an issue.
Traditions change over time, and I'm not sure that things are still done that way in my old neighborhood. This was back in the day when her wedding day was the crowning moment in a young woman's life, as most women in my neighborhood were neither college graduates nor professionals. They would not be going to charity balls, etc so would never have another chance to "dress up like royalty" again, until their children married.