I stayed concierge at the GF two years ago, on points. Yes, you are in the main building, you better be for all those points!!!

And, yes, I also had a bad stay, but I'd stay concierge again. Now, from what I've read, things there have changed, and they have a new GM, and recent reports have been good. It definately something worth doing once, and I would do it again, but I don't think I'd use points, unless I had a bunch to burn. I prefer staying in the outer buildings, and with being used to the room at
DVC, the regular rooms at GF are VERY small. Since they have nicer furniture, it takes up more space, but it is NICE!!! We just stayed at the GF in July, in a lagoon view room, and it was a better stay than in the main building. When we were in the main building, I just didn't get the feel of the resort. Everytime you returned, you just took the elevator upstairs, didn't get to enjoy the beautiful grounds. It was so nice wandering through the grounds each evening after the parks. When we stay at the GF again, we've decided we'll get a one bedroom suite, on the grounds. This way, we get access to all the concierge perks, albeit a walk, but still have access to the beautiful grounds. Believe me, concierge at the GF is nice, but staying in the outer lodge buildings is part of the experience. If someone was to give me a choice between main building concierge and lagoon view, I'd take lagoon view everytime. The views from the main building can be less than desirable, but all the lagoon views are GREAT!! I still remember mine, a complete view of Seven Seas Lagoon, from the Wedding Pavilion to the Main Street Train Station.