Of the steaks I’ve had at Disney-
Shula’s is great! It’s been good every time I’ve been.
I am not a fan of yachtsman, I was so excited about trying it and the bread basket turned out to be the best part of the meal.
I’ve had an amazing steak and a mediocre steak at Boathouse, its also very loud restaurant.
I hesitate to suggest it, but my favorite steak on property was actually at Flying Fish before they changed their menu. I believe they have a New York strip again, but I can’t say if it is the same.