Looks like you are arriving on a Sunday. We have noticed that you have a lot better chance if you are arriving on a Saturday for the week than if you are not arriving until Sunday. A lot of people come in on Saturday and they can fill it up for the week before you get your chance. (We have also noted that people that come in on Friday typically don't seem to have any troubles getting anything they want as they are beating most people coming for the next week). We came in on a Saturday last fall in a non-busy week and still had issues though. I was only able to get them with no issues on our departure day, not any of our MK days (which was our 9th day if you count arrival day). On a mid-week day, it gave me an A&E option for the 3 of us, but when I confirmed, it only gave that A&E FP+ to DD, and moved DH and I to a meet and greet with Mickey Mouse without even warning that it was changing them, splitting us, or not giving us what it showed we were getting. I spent 3 hours that night trying to adjust things, to get what we wanted, get things moved around, etc, and finally managed to get 2 of us to overlapping times that day. Then I spent the next 3 days online all day every day trying to get the last one of us an A&E FP+ that overlapped the other 2, which I was finally able to do. Keep trying- maybe you will be able to switch and get one. As long as you have even 5 minutes of overlapping time, it will work (actually even if you had one that ended 5 minutes before the others started it would work as the Mickey Head will scan green 5 minutes before your FP time, and if not the earlier person could always enter the line and then let people pass while they wait for you to be able to enter). Good luck!