Americans and Canadians culture Q&A Thread.

You never hear anything about Canadian baseball outside of the Blue Jays. Unlike countries like Japan, Korea, and large parts of Latin America where it's huge. There are only 6 Canadians in MLB vs. over 500 from the US.

I'm curious, what do you think we hear about US baseball outside of MLB teams? What exactly are you looking at in those other countries to say baseball is huge there but not in Canada? Where did you get 6 Canadians in MLB because that number is wrong?
 
I'm curious, what do you think we hear about US baseball outside of MLB teams? What exactly are you looking at in those other countries to say baseball is huge there but not in Canada? Where did you get 6 Canadians in MLB because that number is wrong?
Generally from following baseball. Japan and Korea have their own leagues and it's usually a big deal when one of their stars signs with an MLB team. Tons of players in MLB are from Latin American countries. Look back at the results from when baseball was an Olympic sport - the most successful countries were Cuba, Japan, and the US. Canada never medaled and only qualified in 2 out of 6 games.

# of Canadians in MLB was from Google, I didn't count myself.
 

Hey I tried to help - though, to be fair, I didn't bother arguing the popularity, just the lack of US specificness of the "catch phrases"
That is true! (And very much appreciated!)

I am currently trying to determine how long it will take pickleball to overtake soccer on the popularity scale. It seems to be taking off everywhere.
 
Generally from following baseball. Japan and Korea have their own leagues and it's usually a big deal when one of their stars signs with an MLB team. Tons of players in MLB are from Latin American countries. Look back at the results from when baseball was an Olympic sport - the most successful countries were Cuba, Japan, and the US. Canada never medaled and only qualified in 2 out of 6 games.

# of Canadians in MLB was from Google, I didn't count myself.

Given that there are 11 Canadians in MLB teams that made the playoffs, I question your Google skills.

https://canadiansportscene.com/eleven-canadian-mlb-players-in-2022-mlb-postseason/

More than six here too:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Major_League_Baseball_players_from_Canada

And more than six here:
https://sirc.ca/news/2022-mlb-draft...oronto-born Adam,in the 15 Canadians selected.
 
Generally from following baseball. Japan and Korea have their own leagues and it's usually a big deal when one of their stars signs with an MLB team. Tons of players in MLB are from Latin American countries. Look back at the results from when baseball was an Olympic sport - the most successful countries were Cuba, Japan, and the US. Canada never medaled and only qualified in 2 out of 6 games.

# of Canadians in MLB was from Google, I didn't count myself.

In Canada, the only professional sport that has it's own league if the CFL. All others main leagues are connected with the USA. There are plenty of domestic leagues at various levels within Canada but typically top tier professional sports are intertwined in Canada and the US.

As for the Olympics, the qualification system makes it much more difficult for a team from the Americas to qualify.
 
I wasn't googling that stat in particular. Who knew Canadians were so touchy about baseball?

No, we are touchy about inaccuracies. And people who refuse to admit that they misspoke/misquoted.

You said "There are only 6 Canadians in MLB vs. over 500 from the US."

When asked how you came to that number you said "# of Canadians in MLB was from Google, I didn't count myself. "

When it is pointed out that your stat is wrong, you now say "I wasn't googling that stat in particular"

So you just made up the number? Or did you, as you previously said, get it from Google?
 
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-64311705 - What's behind Canada's drastic new alcohol guidance

So to our neighbors to the north I found this article very interesting. I know that my friends in the US would not be following this guidance at all but I wondered what the Canadians thought of this new guidance

Honestly, I probably drink two drinks a year,, but I don't see many people following the rule (or, at least, changing their habits to do so).

Also, it does not appear that Prince Charles (as he was when the picture was taken) enjoys Canadian beer :)
 
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-64311705 - What's behind Canada's drastic new alcohol guidance

So to our neighbors to the north I found this article very interesting. I know that my friends in the US would not be following this guidance at all but I wondered what the Canadians thought of this new guidance
I think the alcohol guidance is probably accurate. It’s a good reminder to drink less. I’m not opposed to anyone putting warning labels on alcohol. Who knows if it will make any difference.
 
Who knew Canadians were so touchy about baseball?
No, we are touchy about inaccuracies.
I know, but it's not as popular in Canada as in the US.
I don't feel like we are touchy about baseball as much as we are touchy about blanket statements/assumptions that aren't backed up with any actual data. You made a comment about baseball not being as popular in Canada as in the U.S., but then didn't provide anything to show what your criteria was to come to that conclusion.

(We are likely a little more overly sensitive, as in the 200+ pages of this topic, this issue has been raised multiple times for other subjects.)
 
No, we are touchy about inaccuracies. And people who refuse to admit that they misspoke/misquoted.

You said "There are only 6 Canadians in MLB vs. over 500 from the US."

When asked how you came to that number you said "# of Canadians in MLB was from Google, I didn't count myself. "

When it is pointed out that your stat is wrong, you now say "I wasn't googling that stat in particular"

So you just made up the number? Or did you, as you previously said, get it from Google?
No, I got it from a link from Google that I went to when searching something else. I did not google "How many Canadians are in MLB?" in particular.

I don't know why my initial post was jumped on in the first place.
 
No, I got it from a link from Google that I went to when searching something else. I did not google "How many Canadians are in MLB?" in particular.

I don't know why my initial post was jumped on in the first place.
Your initial post wasn't "jumped on". It was questioned. As are many on this thread.

You may feel like it was jumped on since you clearly cannot actually defend/back up any of your statements (or even just admit that you misspoke/misquoted). I get it, it can feel judgemental when you are proven wrong.
 
No, I got it from a link from Google that I went to when searching something else. I did not google "How many Canadians are in MLB?" in particular.

I don't know why my initial post was jumped on in the first place.
Having generalizations causes issues on this thread. I’ve learned to avoid talking about many of them myself. @SirDuff is a scientist, so I get why he’s a stickler for 100% accuracy. I’ll admit when I accidentally misspoke something as fact vs opinion, but sometimes I think some on this thread take it to far (like @seshat0120 once trying to inaccurately paint me as a nationalist, which I am not one). For the record @SirDuff, facts that are true are important but people can draw a a range of conclusions from any fact (that doesn’t mean they are all correct either).
 
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-64311705 - What's behind Canada's drastic new alcohol guidance

So to our neighbors to the north I found this article very interesting. I know that my friends in the US would not be following this guidance at all but I wondered what the Canadians thought of this new guidance
That reminds me of a documentary I watched about alcohol. This was for England...it was nuts how they reacted when the recommendation was lowered (it's a documentary on Netflix IIRC). But pub culture (in a different than U.S. way) is big so social drinking takes on a whole new meaning.

Of course I've been seeing studies back and forth for years about "no amount of alcohol is good" "any amount of alcohol is bad for your brain" then "but X amount of wine per week is good for you"...it all goes back and forth. Same for coffee and the back and forth.
 
Having generalizations causes issues on this thread. I’ve learned to avoid talking about many of them myself. @SirDuff is a scientist, so I get why he’s a stickler for 100% accuracy. I’ll admit when I accidentally misspoke something as fact vs opinion, but sometimes I think some on this thread take it to far (like @seshat0120 once trying to inaccurately paint me as a nationalist, which I am not one). For the record @SirDuff, facts that are true are important but people can draw a a range of conclusions from any fact (that doesn’t mean they are all correct either).

Yes, Buzz, I fully agree that interpretation is everything. One of my favourite quotes (which is actually a slight misquote, but I still like it): "If you torture the data long enough, they will admit to anything". You might not have notice (not being snarky, I wouldn't have expected you to notice), but I've not actually made a comment on her view that Americans like baseball more than Canadians do. That is interpretation. @Buzz Rules - legitimately agreeing with you here, not being snarky (though that doesn't stop me from asking people to back-up their interpretations :)).

However, either the statement "There are six Canadian MLB players" is correct or not. That's not an interpretation that is (an attempt) to state a fact.

And, I still say that the "catch phrases" in the link are equally common across the two countries (there is a wide variation among the sayings - with some, in my experience, being really common and others being quite rare).
 
(We are likely a little more overly sensitive, as in the 200+ pages of this topic, this issue has been raised multiple times for other subjects.)
I think that's a fair point but would add the reverse can also be true, assumptions have been made over and over about Americans as well but a correction tends to be drowned out in either sarcasm or outright ignorance of the topic.

Meh happens all around. Like you said it's been more than 200 pages and more than a year..bound to be the case.
 
Southern Americans, I saw this video recently and I’m curious how much of it is satire and how much is based on a kernel of truth:
 





New Posts










Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top