American Idol Top 4 Idol Chatter and Idle Chatter

[damo]

The only ones that really annoyed me were Fantasia and Constantine. Sanjaya because he was on way longer than he deserved to be.

Oh I forgot about Constantine, I didn't like him either. Another one that I thought stayed way too long was Anthony.

 

[WDWRocksMySocks]

Oh, I can definitely do this list!

Contestants that have annoyed me:

1. Taylor Hicks -- How and WHY did he win?!?! And why am I still annoyed by it is a better question. I'm sorry, but Taylor was just all kinds of hideous.
2. Katharine McPhee
3. Fantasia
4. Sanjaya
5. Blake Lewis
6. Megan Joy
7. Kristie Lee Cook
8. Allison

Obviously, I have a low tolerance of annoyance.

 

[wdwgirl03]

Happy Danny Gokey day everyone, I am so excited for the concert/parade later on. Look for me on TV next week.

Oh, and my list of annoying contestants (I didn't really start watching until season 3):
Fantasia
Taylor
Kristy Lee Cook
Kellie Pickler (liked her at first but then she just annoyed the heck out of me)
Megan Joy
Adam (sorry, I do not get him . I am sick of his screeching, I don't care if it's a note or not...you can be the world's best singer and do that and it is STILL ANNOYING! UGH!)

 

[damo]

It confuses me that people who didn't like Taylor like Danny. To me they are interchangable in style and sound. Taylor seemed a lot more considerate of others and less self centered.

 

[feenie]

I liked Taylor Hicks because he was funny to watch. I would never buy one of his cds or see him in concert though.

I'm sad allison is gone, but I would be sad if any of the top 4 had gone.
I like all of them for different reasons.

Although I didn't watch her season, Fantasia drives me up a wall.
I also felt very strongly about Katherine McPhee. When she stayed and Chris went home.... Oh was I mad. (but I didn't vote that night, so I can't talk too much )
Kristi Lee Cook and megan Joy were both annoying too.
Sanjaya was a joke, and mostly it just bothered me that more talented people were sent home before him.

 

[WDWRocksMySocks]

It confuses me that people who didn't like Taylor like Danny. To me they are interchangable in style and sound. Taylor seemed a lot more considerate of others and less self centered.

I guess I don't really see the similarities b/t the two of them...maybe their voices, but even then I think Danny sounds a lot better. I'm not a huge Danny fan, but yikes...comparing him to Taylor?

I also felt very strongly about Katherine McPhee. When she stayed and Chris went home.... Oh was I mad. (but I didn't vote that night, so I can't talk too much )

Ooh, I was so mad too! I tried to vote that entire night and never once got through. I'm still convinced Fox was conspiring against him.

 

[FergieTCat]

I cannot stand David Archuleta. He annoys me to no end. Also, I don't understand why Taylor Hicks won.

 

[Robinrs]

My annoyances:

David Archuleta
Chris Daughtry
Kellie Pickler
Antonella
Kristie Lee Cook

Lots more, I've got to think about it...

 

[Robinrs]

My annoyances:

David Archuleta
Chris Daughtry
Kellie Pickler
Antonella
Kristie Lee Cook

Lots more, I've got to think about it...

Oh yes... KAT McPEE!!!

 

[damo]

Danny just received his song from the judges. It is "Dance Little Sister" by Terence Trent D'arby.

Judges' choice for Kris: Apologize by One Republic.

No word on Adam's song yet.

I don't really think these judges' choices need to be hidden since they will be all over the place by the end of today.

 

[mandy200587]

Kris has a crowd almost as large as the CMA Fest crowd we get in Nashville.

His song is out

 

[daughtersrus]

I wonder how the judges are going to pick. Usually each judge picks a song for one of the contestants. This year, there are 4 judges and 3 contestants. I think that it would be difficult to get all 4 to agree on one song. Maybe they will each write down a title, throw it in hat and the one that gets picked is the one that the contestant has to sing.

 

[kimmar067]

Oh, I can definitely do this list!

Contestants that have annoyed me:

1. Taylor Hicks -- How and WHY did he win?!?! And why am I still annoyed by it is a better question. I'm sorry, but Taylor was just all kinds of hideous.
2. Katharine McPhee
3. Fantasia
4. Sanjaya
5. Blake Lewis
6. Megan Joy
7. Kristie Lee Cook
8. Allison

Obviously, I have a low tolerance of annoyance.

...or of silly hairdo's, or of wacky dancing techniques....

 

[kimmar067]

My annoyances:

David Archuleta
Chris Daughtry
Kellie Pickler
Antonella
Kristie Lee Cook

Lots more, I've got to think about it...

...bikini girl and giggle girl.....

 

[wdwgirl03]

It confuses me that people who didn't like Taylor like Danny. To me they are interchangable in style and sound. Taylor seemed a lot more considerate of others and less self centered.

OK, just curious as to why you think Danny is so self-sentered...I guess I'm just biased though.

 

[wdwgirl03]

...bikini girl and giggle girl.....

Oh, how could I forget about those two?!

 

[Robinrs]

...bikini girl and giggle girl.....

HOW did I forget THEM!!!

I wasn't crazy about Nathaniel, either. I thought he was just RIDICULOUS.

 

[Camicar]

My votes for AI Annoyance would go to:

1. Megan Joy
2. Kellie Pickler

---

My dd will be excited when she gets home today and sees the receipt I've left on her bed showing the purchase of two AI Tour tickets.

 

[blissventure]

...bikini girl and giggle girl.....

HOW did I forget THEM!!!

I wasn't crazy about Nathaniel, either. I thought he was just RIDICULOUS.

I totally agree!!

The unbelievably annoying trifecta:

Win-Bikini Girl
Place-Giggle Girl
Show-Nathaniel

 

[WDWRocksMySocks]

...or of silly hairdo's, or of wacky dancing techniques....

Oh, I just lump those all in the broad category of annoyance.

...bikini girl and giggle girl.....

How, oh how did I forget them?!? I'm seriously off today.

OK, just curious as to why you think Danny is so self-sentered...I guess I'm just biased though.

I think Danny's actions might be misconstrued. I think he's more sarcastic then self-centered or narcissistic. At least that's my take on it.

I totally agree!!

The unbelievably annoying trifecta:

Win-Bikini Girl
Place-Giggle Girl
Show-Nathaniel

Nathaniel won me over with that hilarious reaction to Tatiana getting through. Seriously, I had to watch that over and over b/c I found it so freaking awesome! Um...yeah, I need to get out more. Otherwise, he was pretty obnoxious.