American Idol Thread

[NY Disney fan]

Kristie Lee Cook gave such a great performance on Wednesday that her Vote For the Worst club gave up on her.

 

[MoniqueU]

I am fine with KLC being voted off just wish it had been jason.

I am not liking the themes they have picked for each week this year that much. I am probably in the minority but Broadway Songs bleh. Although even though I can't stand MC this weeks show was good so we will see. I think some of the idols are better then Mariah. LOL David cook certainly is.

 

[damo]

I don't know, I think Jason could put a great spin on Any Dream Will Do, from Joseph.

There are also a few great Jesus Christ Superstar songs he could sing like, What's the Buzz or Herod's song. I'm sure he'll find something.

 

[NY Disney fan]

I am not liking the themes they have picked for each week this year that much. I am probably in the minority but Broadway Songs bleh. .

Hey, at least its not Motown week. How many times do we have to AI contestants sing Ain't No Mountain High Enough.

 

[TnTsParty]

Anyone else think Carly should have covered her tatoos? I thought they looked out of place with a dress like that. Or she should have chosen another outfit.

Actually no I don't think she should HAVE to cover her tattoos. Here in America we have freedom of speech and that would include your freedom to have tattoos and if they happen to show more power to her. No one should be judged by how they appear on the outside - tattoos or not.

 

[damo]

Actually no I don't think she should HAVE to cover her tattoos. Here in America we have freedom of speech and that would include your freedom to have tattoos and if they happen to show more power to her. No one should be judged by how they appear on the outside - tattoos or not.

In some outfits, the tattoos look better covered up. To me, they are like accessories. Sometimes they go with an outfit and sometimes they don't.

I don't think Chattyholic implied that she should HAVE TO cover them but just that she should have with that outfit. It is a personal taste thing.

 

[MoniqueU]

Hey, at least its not Motown week. How many times do we have to AI contestants sing Ain't No Mountain High Enough.

LOL so true.

 

[HoneyBee06]

Just skimmed through some of the posts in this thread.

I think next week they can only sing Andrew Lloyd Webber songs.

No, Carly should not have covered her tattoos. She likes them so she should show them whenever she wants. (Personally, I'm not a fan of tattoos but if she likes them....more power to her.)

I think a lot of people don't like Carly because of her appearance. That's so bizarre to me. She's a great singer.

 

[damo]

Just skimmed through some of the posts in this thread.

I think next week they can only sing Andrew Lloyd Webber songs.

No, Carly should not have covered her tattoos. She likes them so she should show them whenever she wants. (Personally, I'm not a fan of tattoos but if she likes them....more power to her.)

I think a lot of people don't like Carly because of her appearance. That's so bizarre to me. She's a great singer.

It is also bizarre because she is gorgeous!!!

 

[corie161]

I don't have a problem with Carly's tattoo's, but they are a distraction when she's singing. Kind of like wearing a crazy or weird outfit or piece of jewelry would be a distraction. I'd rather be focused on her performing.

I was disappointed that Syesha didn't go before Kristy, but glad Brooke made it through.

 

[HoneyBee06]

I don't have a problem with Carly's tattoo's, but they are a distraction when she's singing. Kind of like wearing a crazy or weird outfit or piece of jewelry would be a distraction. I'd rather be focused on her performing.

I was disappointed that Syesha didn't go before Kristy, but glad Brooke made it through.

Seriously? Syesha might be boring but her voice is a million times better than The Colonel (KLC.)

 

[bicker]

I don't find Syesha's voice that interesting, while Kristy's is (though typically applied to music I don't care for).

 

[puffkin]

I don't find Syesha's voice that interesting, while Kristy's is (though typically applied to music I don't care for).

I agree. I am not a fan of either, and indifferent to who went, but Sayesha sounds like a ton of other singers out there. Very pleasant to listen too, but nothing unique or different about it. KLC had some HORRIBLE performances, but at least her voice was somewhat distinguishable but I just don't enjoy that genre of music.

 

[corie161]

I don't find Syesha's voice that interesting, while Kristy's is (though typically applied to music I don't care for).

I agree. I am not a fan of either, and indifferent to who went, but Sayesha sounds like a ton of other singers out there. Very pleasant to listen too, but nothing unique or different about it. KLC had some HORRIBLE performances, but at least her voice was somewhat distinguishable but I just don't enjoy that genre of music.

That's probably why I preferred KLC over Syesha, I do like that genre of music. I definately didn't think she was going to be the next big country star, but I also didn't think she was that bad. Syesha just bores me, not that she didn't have a great voice, just nothing to go with it.

 

[happygirl]

Actually no I don't think she should HAVE to cover her tattoos. Here in America we have freedom of speech and that would include your freedom to have tattoos and if they happen to show more power to her. No one should be judged by how they appear on the outside - tattoos or not.

To me her tattoos are a distraction whiles she singing, nothing more or less then that. I think it takes votes away from her

 

[MoniqueU]

Did anyone like Elliot Yamins performance last night? I had to fast forward through it because I can't stand the guy.

 

[sassyat30]

Did anyone like Elliot Yamins performance last night? I had to fast forward through it because I can't stand the guy.

No, but I don't care for him.

Who else downloaded "You'll Always be My Baby" (studio version) from itunes?

*proudly raises hand*

 

[sassyat30]

I was also surprised that DC didn't mention his brother when Ryan asked about how emotional he was the night before.

I think he's trying to avoid the sympathy vote.

 

[damo]

I was also surprised that DC didn't mention his brother when Ryan asked about how emotional he was the night before.

I think he's trying to avoid the sympathy vote.

I think it is a private issue.

 

[sassyat30]

I think it is a private issue.

That everyone knows about.