American Idol Season 9

[LiLIrishChick63]

Still doing the corny entrances

i hate that they have the judges making an "entrance" too. i hated it when they started it last season.

 

[StephyDee]

They're all lookin pretty good. No one's going crazy style-wise (that means YOU, Siobhan!)

 

[Nancy]

Randy "we'll see big highs and big lows"....ya think?

 

[Mean Queen]

is Mike SERIOUS with that song choice???

interested to see Lee's song tho, that sounds pretty good. that's pretty much the only Beatles song i even like.

Yes. Very bad choice.

And never put Kara in the same category of song writer as Lennon/Mccartney

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

it was a standout night in season 7?? did someone else besides David Cook sing??



and i wish someone would sing Tool's version of Imagine....

 

[Robinrs]

I love ALL of those songs!!! Time to hear them butchered...

 

[Cat0727]

"arguably some of the best melodies ever created"??? There IS no argument, Kara.

 

[Nancy]

Kara...again with her meaning and relevant crap.

And Simon....geez....that makes absolutely no sense.

 

[StephyDee]

it was a standout night in season 7?? did someone else besides David Cook sing??

Yeah other people sang. I think there was a little kid, a guy with dreads, annnnnd I think someone who sang "8 Days A Week"......oh....the OTHER Cook.....

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

they couldn't have come up with another theme, tho?? they already did this not too long ago.

i mean, i can understand if they did "Queen week" again since that was 4 seasons ago, but Beatles was only 2 seasons ago. i feel like we JUST heard these songs....

 

[Mean Queen]

EVERYONE is going to compare it to DC's version. after Mike butchers it i'm gonna have to go listen to David's version....

It's still one of my ringtones. My main one being his version of "Hello."

I do think this week stood out in Season 7 because some people really excelled (DC) and some just stood out. (CAW CAW!)

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

Yeah other people sang. I think there was a little kid, a guy with dreads, annnnnd I think someone who sang "8 Days A Week"......oh....the OTHER Cook.....

OMG I HAD FORGOTTEN ABOUT KRISTY'S HORRIBLE VERSION OF THAT SONG!!

i'm not even a Beatles fan and even I was like "oh no she did not just try and make a Beatles song COUNTRY....and butcher it completely"

 

[Cat0727]

it was a standout night in season 7?? did someone else besides David Cook sing??



and i wish someone would sing Tool's version of Imagine....

Who else was in David Cook's season besides David Cook? LOL I can't remember anyone else but him.

 

[krcit]

He's butchering my favorite Beatles song.

 

[StephyDee]

I like these intros. They're helping us to see about the contestants more.

I would laugh if they got to Siobhan's clip and the whole thing is one huge SCREEEEEEEEEEEEAAAAAAM, and then at the end, everyone unplugs their ears and goes "Is she done yet?"

 

[Cat0727]

Aaron looks & sounds like he's struggling.

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

It's still one of my ringtones. My main one being his version of "Hello."

I do think this week stood out in Season 7 because some people really excelled (DC) and some just stood out. (CAW CAW!)

Hello is also still one of my ringtones, too!

why aren't the judges calling out the contestants on "playing it safe" anymore? do you think they've just given up? because Aaron singing "Let It Be" isn't surprising at all, i knew he'd pick it. and he doesn't do anything "different" with any of the songs he sings, either.

 

[Nancy]

I love this song and Aaron is doing OK with it.

 

[Mean Queen]

DD10 just walked in and said "This is bad." I said "Yep, pretty much." Then she asked "When will it be over?" I said "Not soon enough."

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

Who else was in David Cook's season besides David Cook? LOL I can't remember anyone else but him.

the other David.....that's all i remember

He's butchering my favorite Beatles song.

yeah that was awful....if they don't call him on that.....