American Idol, Season 5 **Official Discussion Thread**

[J.Cooper]

I agree with Simon, Ace sucked. Elliott did wonderful!!

 

[Nancy]

I love Ace..but that was not good at all...hopefully his looks will get him through tonight so we can hear and see more of him next week.

Elliott...my god...I love his voice! This is going to be a tough year for me to vote...I like way too many of the guys and would love to see anyone of 4 or 5 win.

 

[Slacking]

Brenna grabbing for Ace's beanie when it clearly wasn't thrown at her was hilarious!

 

[damo]

Ya, Ace wasn't the best. I hauled my son off his computer to listen to him and he said the background singers made it sound awful. I'll take that excuse!!!

I liked Taylor until he started throwing the Woo! in there. It destroyed the mood he was developing.

Elliot was awesome. What a voice.

Gedeon was also good.

At least the guys know how to bring it! Or are we in for a lull now???

 

[Poohbear123]

I can't believe he is so young! The guys are defintely much BETTER than the girls this year!

 

[Pig Pen]

1= worse, 10= best

Taylor - 7
Elliott - 8
Ace - 5
Gedeon - 8
Kevin (or is it Chicken Little?) is next.....

 

[Sandy22]

Kevin – just average vocals. He’s too boyish for me…I want to hear from the MEN!

 

[J.Cooper]

Sorry Randy, I don't think Kevin did good? It was boring to me. I'm agreeing with Simon's comments this season?

 

[Pig Pen]

Kevin .... ho hum.

 

[Nancy]

1= worse, 10= best

Taylor - 7
Elliott - 8
Ace - 5
Gedeon - 8
Kevin (or is it Chicken Little?) is next.....

Too Funny.... they just showed a picture of Chicken Little next to Kevin!

 

[Pig Pen]

Hey! They stole my Chicken Little joke!!!

Sway is next. He is lucky to be there after last week's performance...

 

[Sandy22]

Sway is next. He is lucky to be there after last week's performance...

No kidding. He better not sing that falsetto stuff again.

 

[Tigger&Belle]

OMG, Sway is horrible!

 

[Tigger&Belle]

Who was the second guy to be voted off last week?

 

[KathyTX]

Sway... ick. Talk about pitchy!

Gideon really surprised me- the kid was quite good!

Ace... so cute, so very boooorrrrring tonight...

Taylor's my man, his performances just make me smile.

Elliott- sounded good, but I can't get past his looks.

Kevin- cute kid, very lucky to have made it this far.

 

[J.Cooper]

Sway was very pitchy!!! Not a good performance.

 

[Pig Pen]

Sway was agonizing! Unfortunately I have agreed with almost everything Simon has said tonight.

I am trying to figure out what purpose Paula Abdul serves. She is such a pollyanna and is so circumspect!

 

[Lisa loves Pooh]

that's ace, and i did not think his falsetto sounded good at all. i don't think that was a good song choice

An unhandsome moment--and for some reason...I was thinking during this performance--he'd look really hot in High School Musical (gotta getcha get your head in the game).


Okay--I am working and keep getting phone calls--so I am now only catching bits and pieces of the show. Of course one daughter loves everyone and one daughter doesn't like any of them.

 

[Pig Pen]

Who was the second guy to be voted off last week?

Robbie (reminded me of Jackie Gleason) and maybe Patrick?

 

[Pig Pen]

Ryan sounded okay. It was just boring.