American Idol, Season 5 **Official Discussion Thread**

[llij]

Taylor was GREAT!

My favs are Taylor, Ace and Chris!

 

[Pig Pen]

So do I...here are my top picks from tonight:

1. Chris
2. Ace
3. Taylor
4. Elliott

 

[theSurlyMermaid]

Taylor was GREAT!

My favs are Taylor, Ace and Chris!

Taylor is AWESOME.

I agree with your faves!

 

[tevagirl]

In order: Taylor, Chris, Ace.

 

[dolphindan1]

Taylor
Chris
Wil
Ace

 

[twoksmom]

So do I...here are my top picks from tonight:

1. Chris
2. Ace
3. Taylor
4. Elliott

I agree with your picks. I would even add Bucky to #5.That southern rock thing and all.April

 

[J.Cooper]

Favs = Chris, Gedeon, Taylor & Sway.

I think once Simon looks at the performances again, he'll regret his comment about Elliott.

 

[damo]

Same top picks here although I can't decide on the order. Chris, Ace, Taylor and Elliot. Each brings something different to the table.

I was really happy to see that Taylor didn't do the Elaine Bennis dance. He reminds me of a 3 year old who is really big for his age and you expect him to act so much older then you remember he is only 3.

The young guys just seem so...young.

 

[disnygoof]

OMG, he is so great!! He's so fresh, original and has his OWN style! Not like the cookie cutter pop singers like most of the other contestants. He truly LOVES music and I hope he goes all the way!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[LadyBears]

My top 4 in no particular order are:

Chis
Bucky
Ace
Taylor

 

[llij]

I missed Gedeon, Elliot and Bobby singing tonight so I can't say how they were, but overall I thought the guys were better than the girls.

 

[Pig Pen]

Favs = Chris, Gedeon, Taylor & Sway.

I think once Simon looks at the performances again, he'll regret his comment about Elliott.

I know! I am still stumped about that.

I forgot about Gedeon. I may move him up to #4 and Elliott down.

See everyone tomorrow night. I will be taping AI and watching Survivor so no disboards until late!!!

 

[tevagirl]

I missed Gedeon, Elliot and Bobby singing tonight so I can't say how they were, but overall I thought the guys were better than the girls.

I agree. I think the guys have it over the girls too.

 

[dolphindan1]

Favs = Chris, Gedeon, Taylor & Sway.

I think once Simon looks at the performances again, he'll regret his comment about Elliott.

Did you watch with the sound on....Chris yes.....Taylor yes....Sway and Gedeon not in the top 5...of course I think Gedeon is better than what he did tonight vocally

 

[cheeringmom]

Barry's not dead....but that might have done it.

hahaha

pretty funny!

I loved Chris, Bucky and Taylor.

 

[palmtreegirl]

Patrick
David-
Bucky- Decent.
Will- Yeh, no, that was terrible.
Jose "Sway" whatever- I'm so confused Paula and Randy were hearing what we heard? Amazing? yeh amazingly bad.
Chris- Wow, he has a great voice.
I really, really, really dislike Paula
Kevin- I'm beginning to wonder how some of these guys got in the final 24.
Gideon- I liked him, he was a lot of fun with a great voice.
Elliot- I really like his voice, it has a great quality to it and I like that he didn't need all the glory notes. He has a powerful voice yet it's still masculine and not Broadway.
Bobby- I thought...
Ace- Am I the only one that doesn't think he's hot? Yeh, I am? OK. George Michael? Interesting choice. :
Taylor- I can't be bias because I hate the song he sung, I'll wait till next week.

Top picks- Chris, Elliot and Gideon

 

[ntburns22]

I agree. I think the guys have it over the girls too.

I agree with this too! Some of the guys will be sent home that deserve a spot in the top 12 over some of the girls. I don't think the 6 guys 6 girls is fair.

 

[MinnieM3]

Oh Man!!! Ace can be my Daddy anytime!!! THAT WAS HOTTTT!!!!!!

Oh so ditto!!!!

 

[KathyTX]

He reminds me of a 3 year old who is really big for his age and you expect him to act so much older then you remember he is only 3.

That's EXACTLY what Taylor's like! He just has a real joy about him.

My top three are Chris, Ace and Taylor, by a LANDSLIDE. All of the others really pale compared to these three.

And I agree, ladies- this could be a dangerous season.

 

[cheeringmom]

I agree with this too! Some of the guys will be sent home that deserve a spot in the top 12 over some of the girls. I don't think the 6 guys 6 girls is fair.

never cared for that "rule" either. A lot more talent in the guy catagory but there are a few girls-Lisa T-that will give them a run for their money.

Taylor is a hometown boy. The southerners will have busy phones for the next two hours!!