American Idol, Season 5 Official Discussion Thread

Fan2CSkr · Mar 9, 2006

What a let down. I love Bo, but that was not good.

Slacking · Mar 9, 2006

Yeah, he pretty much made the same watered down album he would have made if he won AI. I am not impressed by what I've heard of his CD.

Kinnik booted? What a SHOCK!!! lol

lillygator · Mar 9, 2006

we loved Bo too but wow I love his LS covers better than this...

and now K and W....no surprise there!

Obi-Wan Pinobi · Mar 9, 2006

No surprises yet! Although we are sad to see Will go. He's got potential.

Can a contestant that makes it to the top 24 ever compete again? Like could Will come back in 2-3 yrs when he is more mature and compete again?

That is saying AI would be around in 2-3 yrs

Obi-Wan Pinobi · Mar 9, 2006

Getting rid of that link to DialIdol now..LMAO :rotfl2:

J.Cooper · Mar 9, 2006

Looks like the spoilers were wrong. Lisa made it to the top 12? I hope Melissa makes it.

Obi-Wan Pinobi · Mar 9, 2006

It must be Ayla - Melissa would not be a big surprise as Nigel hinted at

J.Cooper · Mar 9, 2006

Yeah Melissa made it!! I feel bad for Ayla though!

Obi-Wan Pinobi · Mar 9, 2006

I feel bad for her too. Geez, don't make her sing again, the poor kid is crying.

Planogirl · Mar 9, 2006

I hope that Bo can make an album in his own style of music now. The AI music so totally doesn't work for him.

Awww, poor Ayla. Good for Melissa though. Kinnik and Wil weren't surprises though.

Cindy B · Mar 9, 2006

Poor Ayla she's crying when she's singing!

But you know what, that would have really screwed with her scholarship.

Cindy B · Mar 9, 2006

Gedeon or Bucky...who could it be?

Planogirl · Mar 9, 2006

It looks bad for Bucky.

Fan2CSkr · Mar 9, 2006

Gotta be Gedeon :confused3

Sandy22 · Mar 9, 2006

Why on earth is AI giving more exposure to those ridiculous Brittemen twins? :confused3

Sandy22 · Mar 9, 2006

I'm thinking it's Geddeon - which is too bad because he has more talent than some of the others. Comes down to personality though.

It was nice to see that Ayla has a personality.

Planogirl · Mar 9, 2006

Yay Bucky!!!! It's too bad about Gedeon though.

J.Cooper · Mar 9, 2006

I disagree for the with vote for the guys. I think Kevin should've got the boot not Gideon.

Andrea · Mar 9, 2006

J.Cooper said:
I disagree for the with vote for the guys. I think Kevin should've got the boot not Gideon.

i agree with this

Sandy22 · Mar 9, 2006

What a great performance by Geddeon! You have to respect his confidence and vocal ability. I think he's got a solid career ahead of him.

American Idol, Season 5 **Official Discussion Thread**

If you can judge a wise man by the color of his sk

Secretly has the hots for Bloody Mary

DIS Legend

<font color=red>Jedi moderator who likes to live o

<font color=red>Jedi moderator who likes to live o

I need a vacation<br><font color="red">Been flying

<font color=red>Jedi moderator who likes to live o

I need a vacation<br><font color="red">Been flying

<font color=red>Jedi moderator who likes to live o

I feel the nerd in me stirring

<font color=blue>Have taken some furniture polish

<font color=blue>Have taken some furniture polish

I feel the nerd in me stirring

If you can judge a wise man by the color of his sk

<font color=magenta>Adopting a Princess<br><font c

<font color=magenta>Adopting a Princess<br><font c

I feel the nerd in me stirring

I need a vacation<br><font color="red">Been flying

DIS Veteran<br><font color=<009977>I couldnt decid

<font color=magenta>Adopting a Princess<br><font c

American Idol, Season 5 Official Discussion Thread