American Idol, Season 5 **Official Discussion Thread**

[Cindy B]

I found a picture of Kellie Pickler's prom dress from a few years ago... warning.. it can be considered a fairly risque picture.

My parents would kill me if I went out of the house with that!

http://i1.tinypic.com/s3dn36.jpg

Yes, Kellie Pickler picked an um... interesting dress

 

[Kimberle]

I found a picture of Kellie Pickler's prom dress from a few years ago... warning.. it can be considered a fairly risque picture.

My parents would kill me if I went out of the house with that!

http://i1.tinypic.com/s3dn36.jpg

Yes, Kellie Pickler picked an um... interesting dress

Yikes! I've seen bathing suits cover more!

 

[Obi-Wan Pinobi]

I found a picture of Kellie Pickler's prom dress from a few years ago... warning.. it can be considered a fairly risque picture.

My parents would kill me if I went out of the house with that!

http://i1.tinypic.com/s3dn36.jpg

Yes, Kellie Pickler picked an um... interesting dress

Is dress even the appropriate word here?

Wow, I'm surprised a high school would allow dresses like that on their students. Where did she get it? Fredericks of Hollywood?

 

[damo]

She doesn't look quite so naive and neglected there does she? Nice figure though!

 

[Disney1fan2002]

I found a picture of Kellie Pickler's prom dress from a few years ago... warning.. it can be considered a fairly risque picture.

My parents would kill me if I went out of the house with that!

http://i1.tinypic.com/s3dn36.jpg

Yes, Kellie Pickler picked an um... interesting dress

Where did you find the picture? I ask, because the 1st thing I noticed is how her face looks "off" from the rest of her. I think it is a photoshopped picture.

 

[Cindy B]

Where did you find the picture? I ask, because the 1st thing I noticed is how her face looks "off" from the rest of her. I think it is a photoshopped picture.

another forum based website which features all contestants of american idol. I didn't take the picture. Just shared it.

I don't think its photoshopped. I looked at it for a while. Again, thought it was interesting enough to share though.

 

[damo]

another forum based website which features all contestants of american idol. I didn't take the picture. Just shared it.

I don't think its photoshopped. I looked at it for a while.

Doesn't look photoshopped to me either. Might not be her, but it doesn't look photoshopped.

There are some other cute pictures here: http://www.kelliefans.com/gallery/showgallery.php?cat=506&page=2&perpage=24

from her other events.

 

[Cindy B]

Doesn't look photoshopped to me either. Might not be her, but it doesn't look photoshopped.

The face looks like her. If you look, it appears to be an older picture.

 

[Pluto's Honey]

Not sure about the pic but did go to the american idol website and watched the top 12 photo shoot video and she talked like a normal person not at all ditzy...

http://www.idolonfox.com/videos/?vid=224

 

[Pluto's Honey]

About Taylor's hair color...I would have thought if they were going to change it then it would have been before the actual competing started after the audition. We all change our hair color but with his he's kinda kown by it. Would I stop voting for him if he did? No Did we stop voting for Mandisa when she got her highlights. Which BTW look great!! I thought when they shaped his hair after they got to the top12 it had a darker underneath added, but it could have always been there.

 

[damo]

I just asked my 17 year old son if he thought that the dress was appropriate. He did not hesitate to say yes!!!

 

[Cindy B]

Not sure about the pic but did go to the american idol website and watched the top 12 photo shoot video and she talked like a normal person not at all ditzy...

http://www.idolonfox.com/videos/?vid=224

Thats because its all an act.

 

[reddixie]

Bette Midler would be GREAT! She so talented and personable and experienced that I think that she would fit right in. Dolly Parton is sweet and a very funny lady but I don't know how much knowledge she would have. I'm kind of surprised that Gladys Knight isn't on there. I always liked her.

As for Bucky taking someone's spot, I don't think that's a fair comment. He won fair and square by getting more votes than those who left just like they got more votes themselves before they were voted off. This has nothing to do with saying that you like a performer or not, it's just acknowledging that they won their spot.

Dolly not have enough knowledge hmmm. Ok she did write the number one pop/country love song of all time. I will always love you. She is like Loretta Lynn and really keeps up with music. Also she needs to give comments on stage presence, sound, in tune or not, and such. Well considering that she just earned her 25th number one song in a duet with Brad Paisley and has been singing since the 60's well I think she is very qualified. I think she would be a hoot. She probably wouldn't do this though as she is extremely busy and has her hands full with her dinner shows, theme park, music career, writing her life as a Broadway Musical, and finally her own record label where she promotes new talent. Hmmm ok off my soapbox now. DON'T MESS WITH DOLLY!

 

[DVC Sadie]

Is dress even the appropriate word here?

Wow, I'm surprised a high school would allow dresses like that on their students. Where did she get it? Fredericks of Hollywood?

ITA. Is this the same girl that didn't know what ballsy meant the other night? Yeah right, she is the epitome of ballsy.

 

[Lisa loves Pooh]

Dolly not have enough knowledge hmmm. Ok she did write the number one pop/country love song of all time. I will always love you. She is like Loretta Lynn and really keeps up with music.

And she also wrote an oscar nominated song---in less than one day!!!!

Dude--if I tried to write something in one day. Let's just hope it is good enough so that the cats don't start meowing and glass starts breaking.

She's also not a sell out--she will not write music just to get it on the radio...she writes and sings what she wants (saw an interview for her once--and she had a very postiive outlook despite not getting much airplay or something on her albums).

 

[damo]

I saw Dolly on Ellen not too long ago. She was very funny, smart, down to earth and would probably do a great job.

 

[MOMOFMNM]

personally I love Chris and Love his songs but....

I don't know that I liked his rendition of Walk the Line...It was fine but kinda a stretch for me....anyone else??

 

[Lisa loves Pooh]

personally I love Chris and Love his songs but....

I don't know that I liked his rendition of Walk the Line...It was fine but kinda a stretch for me....anyone else??

I didn't like it.

 

[Nancy]

She doesn't look quite so naive and neglected there does she? Nice figure though!

Damo..my thoughts exactly...doesn't seem like such a backwoods gal in that shot...belly button ring and all!

 

[damo]

cute Kevin post-boot interview: http://www.ew.com/ew/report/0,6115,1176142_3_0_,00.html