All in all, I agree it was a very disappointing night. I'm 48 years old, but still love rock. Loved Chris's version of What If. Thought it was better than the Creed version.
I also love Drops of Jupitor, but thought Ace did a terrible job with it. To me, he's not really good looking either. There's something weird about his eyebrows.
Mandisa was just ok. Paula's comments were totally inappropriate though.
I like Kellie and, unlike many here, I like her personality. Tonight, she was boring.
I though Bucky was good. Of course, I always think he's good. I like his raspy voice and country personality.
Taylor's always one of my favorites and tonight was no exception. Even though I'd never heard of the song, I thought he did a really good job with it and showed a different side of himself.
Paris was pretty good. DD thought she was great. I'm not a Paris or Beyonce fan though.
Elliott was good, although I like Bo's version better. I still think Elliott has a great voice for the right kind of song.
My vote for worst of the night was Katharine. DH, DD and I were wondering if we were hearing the same thing as the judges. To us, she sounded off-key and like she was trying to sing too high for her voice. Don't like her, but usually like her singing. Tonight was just awful, though.
Can't comment about Lisa since I missed the beginning of the show. I'm not really a fan though.
but if i could've, i would have voted for taylor and elliot! they were FAAAANNNNTASTIC. mandisa was very good also, although i don't really enjoy gospel music. everyone else was either horrid (kellie, katherine) or boring (ace, lisa)....IMHO of course. 
Even Paris & Bucky who I don't care for did well tonight IMO. Taylor was good as always. Chris seems like he's singing the same song week after week now. Ace is boring as ever but as long as Lisa & Kellie (horrible!) are in the hunt, he should be safe. Love Mandisa but she screams a little too much. Elliot was good but I did notice that he seemed to forget the words there in the beginning. In short, bye bye Lisa...
I loved Bucky!!! I want to commend Mandisa on stepping out and singing gospel, I believe she did that on the first night also. I almost didn't recognize Kellie, cause someone was reading our board and toned her down. 
I was glad to see Paula giving negative not just positive. i do believe with them singing newer songs we judged them harder cause we know them better. Tomorrow night will be all up in the air. I think anything is possible except Taylor being in the bottom 3, evertime we called him we were busy!! Everytime!! The only one that happened too. 
