American Idol: Season 11 OFFICIAL thread!

[Robinrs]

What is with the oversized rings. Like every female performer wears them.

It's a trend. Even the girls at my office wear them.

 

[maslex]

Seriously?

I was so sure that Heejun was going. I do not like him at all. I don't like his singing and I don't find him funny. But to each is own.

Even though Erika isn't one of my faves, she sure didn't belong in the bottom three. I would have had Heejun & Deandre in there for sure with Heejun going home tonight and Deandre next week. If that boy swings his head one more time and jumps around like a wild monkey, I'm gonna scream!!!

 

[disney1990]

My guess is Jessica, Hollie or Colton.

I think Heejun ticked off Steven last night and the way Jlo was talking I think she thought he was gone tonight.

I think they will only save Colton, Phillip or Jessica.

 

[Disney Doll]

I can't believe Heejun is still in this.
He stinks.
And Deandre is a close second to him.

 

[Jennasis]

Yay Heejun!! So happy he sticks around. I liked Erika much better than Deandre (or Elise, who i thought was going).

 

[TLSnell1981]

I like Erika..she didn't deserve to go this week. Although, I knew they wouldn't keep Elise and Erika.

Heejun stunk. He should've been the one and he knows it.

 

[asta]

Finally watched tonight's show. I am so thankful for my DVR and the fast forward button.

Erika was definitely not the right one to go home. There were several others that I would have liked to go before her. Going early in the performance order probably really did her in.

 

[FINFAN]

Hi all...ok so I dvr'd so I could selectively watch the parts I wanted , and happily FF past the *guest- cough- performers, cough-cough*

Opening number, all I am gong to say is they are lucky the acting in the commercial was worse, as it made me forget about how bad the group number was.
So, did TH have anything to do with tonight's outfits? 'Cause if he did :scared

Ahhhhh Casey Abram's...as scruffy/wolfmanish as ever-I miss you're scary stalker expressions Casey...I know we have PP, but he doesn't do psycho like you did....just constipation (no flames, I like PP/ Dave Mathews 2.0), but c'mon~it's like he has to go to the bathroom REALLY bad

Was fun to see Joe Perry(the long haired version of Colton's Pepe 'do)..and Liv in the audience with Milo...the Tyler lip gene lives on yet another generation!

Onto the elimination~
Really? REALLY?????
Erika goes already?
I guess Heejun has now been handed the Sanjaya slot of the season.

Erika was really trying to hang in there but she knew as soon as her name was called no save was going to take place...especially after she was a wild card just like Jeremy. I know they saved a wild card on the past(Stefano maybe?)..but they will wait until they are closer to the top 5. Overall a boring night, glad I recorded it. I did not catch what next weeks theme is tho...did they say?


ETA: After reading the Dolly Parton comment I had to go back and see what I missed..I am pretty sure it is about my FAVORITE contestant from last season... omg...maybe SHE'S the Sanjaya...

 

[DianeV]

I'm so disappointed Erika went home. Not sure why she didnt appeal to enough people. Maybe it IS the teenage thing and she was one of the 'older' girls. Its too bad because she is really good and now we have to continue to see HeeJun who has gotten old to me. Funny at first but now is the joke. And Deandre too. Very annoying.

Well another typical American Idol season I guess...

 

[TLSnell1981]

I'm so disappointed Erika went home. Not sure why she didnt appeal to enough people. Maybe it IS the teenage thing and she was one of the 'older' girls. Its too bad because she is really good and now we have to continue to see HeeJun who has gotten old to me. Funny at first but now is the joke. And Deandre too. Very annoying.

Well another typical American Idol season I guess...

They are heavily supported by the worst website.

 

[aprilgail2]

I can't believe Heejun is still in this.
He stinks.
And Deandre is a close second to him.

I can't believe those two are there in the first place! I think this is the worst group ever to be picked to be on idol! Last year I went to the concert but no way would I pay to go see this bunch of clowns!

 

[Mean Queen]

I can't believe those two are there in the first place! I think this is the worst group ever to be picked to be on idol! Last year I went to the concert but no way would I pay to go see this bunch of clowns!

I'm wondering if Deandre's appeal is he is a cutie and HeeJun is entertaining (a la Norman Gentle). Not that I think they should be there over Erica. I don't think this is the worst season, that was definitely last season for me... the one Robin referred to as Hee Haw Idol. At least this year they've branched out the musical types so we all have someone to root for, but that will make it even harder for people to agree and pick a winner.

 

[FINFAN]

I liked that Erika had party toys with for the bottom 3, lol. I'm guessing Elise told her how lonely it is over there so she was going to change that! It was light-hearted, a side of her I liked seeing. I think Elise needs to show less anxiety and disappointment,and more confidence. Maybe escaping the bottom 3 this week will help that. You can read her face like a book and it can almost be distracting. I find myself looking to see if she is going to make a face more than listening to her sing. I, do still like her in my top 3 tho (of personal preference~not necessarily who I think will win)
At least Erika made the tour...meh, life in a mansion isn't all that great~ remember the leaky roof last year? It is odd that only 9 go and not all 10. Geeze, they couldn't get a big enough place for 10?

 

[Robinrs]

I can't believe those two are there in the first place! I think this is the worst group ever to be picked to be on idol! Last year I went to the concert but no way would I pay to go see this bunch of clowns!

I don't think this group comes even close to the horridity (is that a word?) of the past two years. I haven't had a favorite since Adam Lambert!

This year I actually like 3 or 4 of them and don't dislike ANY of them. Sure, some are worse than others but I haven't gotten to the "omg that person is on I think I want to blow up my television" like I did for seasons 9 and 10. They pandered to certain tastes, at least this year is a bit more diverse.

 

[Robinrs]

I'm wondering if Deandre's appeal is he is a cutie and HeeJun is entertaining (a la Norman Gentle). Not that I think they should be there over Erica. I don't think this is the worst season, that was definitely last season for me... the one Robin referred to as Hee Haw Idol. At least this year they've branched out the musical types so we all have someone to root for, but that will make it even harder for people to agree and pick a winner.

Sorry, I think I said the exact same thing in my post after yours!

They are heavily supported by the worst website.

Only Heejun is so far, they had Migrane the weeks before him. Deandre is next if Heejun goes, no doubt.

Hi all...ok so I dvr'd so I could selectively watch the parts I wanted , and happily FF past the *guest- cough- performers, cough-cough*

Opening number, all I am gong to say is they are lucky the acting in the commercial was worse, as it made me forget about how bad the group number was.
So, did TH have anything to do with tonight's outfits? 'Cause if he did :scared

Ahhhhh Casey Abram's...as scruffy/wolfmanish as ever-I miss you're scary stalker expressions Casey...I know we have PP, but he doesn't do psycho like you did....just constipation (no flames, I like PP/ Dave Mathews 2.0), but c'mon~it's like he has to go to the bathroom REALLY bad

Was fun to see Joe Perry(the long haired version of Colton's Pepe 'do)..and Liv in the audience with Milo...the Tyler lip gene lives on yet another generation!

Onto the elimination~
Really? REALLY?????
Erika goes already?
I guess Heejun has now been handed the Sanjaya slot of the season.

Erika was really trying to hang in there but she knew as soon as her name was called no save was going to take place...especially after she was a wild card just like Jeremy. I know they saved a wild card on the past(Stefano maybe?)..but they will wait until they are closer to the top 5. Overall a boring night, glad I recorded it. I did not catch what next weeks theme is tho...did they say?


ETA: After reading the Dolly Parton comment I had to go back and see what I missed..I am pretty sure it is about my FAVORITE contestant from last season... omg...maybe SHE'S the Sanjaya...

Clasic FINFAN!!!

 

[mandy200587]

WOOHOOO!!!! We got a modern theme next week!!!! It is personal idols and via Nigel's twitter

Nigel Lythgoe ‏ @dizzyfeet next week they're singing their #IDOL's songs. Beyonce, Mariah, Miranda, Lifehouse, Daughtry, Led Zeppelin. Now that should be interesting?

 

[mandy200587]

Plus Guest Performers are

Nicki Minaj and Scotty McCreery

 

[Robinrs]

WOOHOOO!!!! We got a modern theme next week!!!! It is personal idols and via Nigel's twitter

Nigel Lythgoe ‏ @dizzyfeet next week they're singing their #IDOL's songs. Beyonce, Mariah, Miranda, Lifehouse, Daughtry, Led Zeppelin. Now that should be interesting?

Old fart can live without new songs... don't know them at all!

And I repeat, their guest budget must be minus 3 dollars.

 

[daughtersrus]

Plus Guest Performers are

Nicki Minaj

Good thing for DVRs.

I just didn't get her performance on the Grammys

 

[FINFAN]

Good thing for DVRs.

I just didn't get her performance on the Grammys

ITA....I guess my DVR is getting workout next week as well. Thanks for the list Mandy. Only one I like on there is Miranda and we all know Skylar chose her, lol. Let's see, it would be a hoot if Heejun is the one who chose Zeppelin~ afterall they were already butchered last season,