American Idol Season 10: Official Thread!!

[Nancy]

Oh crap, I missed Stefano because I was posting about Scotty

didn't miss too much, Bruno Mars he is not.

there's MAYBE 4 country songs i like, IF that...and most of them you can actually play on regular radio stations or even in the club or something.

i just can't with "omg my dawg and my pick up truck and my wife cheated on me"

I can't remember the last time I heard a song about any of those things....weeeelllll, OK, Toby Keith does songs about some of those, but never includes a dog. LOL

 

[JessicaR]

sometimes i think the judges get paid or something for pimping certain contestants because clearly there have been some AWFUL performances and the judges will still somehow manage to praise them.

I agree with this to some extent. I think Randy is staying true - sometimes.

What the heck is going on. Didnt seem that way earlier on. But tonight - UGH!

 

[Robinrs]

OmG, JLo made the worse cringe during one of those NOTES and she PRAISED HIM!! Could it be more obvious they're reading their producer notes?????

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

If you think all country is like that you haven't listened lately

you're right, i haven't. i don't listen to country unless it's on at work on the "soft rock" station or whatever it's called.

but to be fair i hardly listen to the radio anymore, period.

 

[Mean Queen]

i think i'd rather vote for the generic rocker guy in the video going to and from commerical than any of these guys to be honest.....

That's because he looks a lot like David Cook.

 

[ShuisFan584]

OmG, JLo made the worse cringe during one of those NOTES and she PRAISED HIM!! Could it be more obvious they're reading their producer notes?????

I didn't even notice that because I'm too busy looking at my computer screen.

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

That's because he looks a lot like David Cook.

lmao that's VERY true. *sigh* David......













sorry.....my mind kind of wandered off for a minute there. i'm back now.

 

[fairestoneofall]

That's because he looks a lot like David Cook.

i was thinking the same thing!

and i also noticed JLo's cringe. i was cringing too.

seriously. they can sing ANY song. i cannot believe some of the song choices tonight. i would pick a song that i was 150% certain i could blow out of the water.

 

[Mean Queen]

didn't miss too much, Bruno Mars he is not.



I can't remember the last time I heard a song about any of those things....weeeelllll, OK, Toby Keith does songs about some of those, but never includes a dog. LOL

Isn't one of the most popular country crossover hits right now about a drunken late night booty call?

 

[DarthKTrava]

you're right, i haven't. i don't listen to country unless it's on at work on the "soft rock" station or whatever it's called.

but to be fair i hardly listen to the radio anymore, period.

All we have at work is muzak. At least it's not elevator muzak but it's the same 40-odd songs over and over every single day. Makes me want to start taking my ipod again.....

 

[ShuisFan584]

I love that floral suit.

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

i don't remember this guy at ALL

 

[FINFAN]

Scotty ...what a smooth dose of country! I need to get past him rmeinding me of the cover of Mad Magazine...get that boy a good ol' cowboy hat! I am a fan for sure!
Stefano, other than the high notes...pretty much the type of singer I see him as..and since Bruno Mars is so popular now, good celebrity to try and connecet with.
Getting closer ot the pimp spot with Casey! Looking forward to Paul!
gREAT SONG CHOICE FOR HIM!
however.....ummm, a little too obvious,,, not really pulling it off...ooooohhhhhh, liked looking at him, did not like listening to him

 

[DianeV]

Our whole household: James and Scotty best of the night so far..dont know what the judges are hearing on some of the others..yuck!

Love Paul so far too!

 

[chisnpeke]

This guy is good.

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

Isn't one of the most popular country crossover hits right now about a drunken late night booty call?

you just said CROSSOVER tho......

 

[Nancy]

Oh...now THIS is a good song choice for him.

 

[Hollywoodhaha]

I'm so done with tonight..
See y'all tomorrow!

 

[Mean Queen]

I love, love, love Paul's voice. This is a perfect song for him.

 

[DarthKTrava]

Isn't one of the most popular country crossover hits right now about a drunken late night booty call?

What song is that?

And Paul McDonald sounds like a very pale, very gay Rod Stewart. A BAD Rod Stewart.