American Idol fans: Whos going to be in the Bottom 3?

[Robinrs]

and BOY where we off last week!! About who was leaving, that is!

I still think Julia will be in the bottom 3, along with Carmen and Corey.

Any other guesses?

 

[becka]

Julia, Carmen and Trenyce although I am not sure about Trenyce it could be Rickey or Corey. That 3rd position will be close.

Julia should finally be on her way home tonight.

 

[sncbird]

The first name that pops into my mind is Julia (although I didn't think she did to bad yesterday). Then I would have to say Carmen and then Corey (just because I'm not a big fan of his). I think Julia's going to get the boot!!

 

[snoopy]

My picks would be Julia, Ricky and Corey.

 

[Poohbear123]

Carmen, Julia and Corey!

 

[WDW Poly Princess]

Julia and Corey for sure.. I'm not sure about the 3rd-
Carmen was pretty decent last night, plus it was her birthday, so she might escape the bottom 3 this time
Ricky has such a great personality, but none of his recent performances have been really outstanding, so he may be down there too.
Trenyce is another maybe. She's been so good up until last night, but she just doesn't have the huge following that others like Clay or Josh have.

 

[GoofieRuthie]

Carmen, Julia, and Corey.

I really hope that Julia or Carmen is out this week. I'm not fond of Rickey's singing at all, but he does seem like a nice guy. I must say that I was rather flustered about them not singing "Country ROCK" like they were supposed to. I love Clay dearly, but I agree that he has the Broadway voice(which is a GOOD thing in my book). I can also hear him singing a Disney theme song for some reason. Anyone else just KNOW that Ruben was gonna sing Sweet Home Alabama? lol He did do a great job on it though.

 

[Minnie824]

I agree.....Julia and Corey for sure....and after last night, I think possibly Ricky. Please, let Julia leave!!! I'm so sick of her and she can't sing good....she chooses songs that you hear the background people singing, so people dont have to hear just her.

 

[disykat]

It should be Carmen, Julia, and Corey IMO. Not sure it will actually work out that way though. I think Trenyce has enough obvious vocal talent that she won't get voted out unless she has another bad week. I do think Ricky is in danger also although he wouldn't be my pick to go yet. I would send Corey home hands down. Although he has a certain charisma, he just can't sing - I don't get why they keep telling him he can. Although Julia hasn't done well lately, at least she could sing in the beginning. I haven't seen anything vocally I've liked in Corey - except the higher phrase of his song last night.

 

[LuvTigger]

I agree, definitely Julia and Corey. IMHO, I thought Julia should have gone home two weeks ago!

Hard to pick the 3rd though...I guess I'd have to say Carmen. Does anyone else think that Simon has been kinder to Carmen than he would be with someone older?

 

[FOJMO]

JULIA - CARMEN - and I don't care who else, as long as they're both off and REAL SOON!

 

[Dodie]

Julia, Carmen and Corey.

I think that Julia should GO! Of course, I've thought that the last two weeks and somehow she's stuck around.

 

[cinmell]

Julia, Corey and Carmen probably.

 

[CJK]

In order........
Julia, Carmen & Corey

Trenyce was particularly bad last night, but hopefully her performance on past shows will help her from getting the boot. I think Ricky will continue to slip under the radar for a while. The above 3 mentioned should be the next ones to go (IMHO)!!!

 

[suzannen]

Although Julia performed better last night than she has, she still tops my bottom list followed, in order, by Corey and Carmen. Corey didn't even sing a country-rock song!

 

[DiznEeyore]

I'm gonna echo everyone else who said Julia, Carmen & Corey. But I think it's Miss Julia's night to go.

 

[100%Disney]

I would like to see Corey go, I think he has been kissing up way too much to make up for the night on the town he spent. There's just something about him, he shmoozes too much and Paula falls for it, yuk. I want to see Clay win.

 

[GoofieRuthie]

I think he's getting by solely on looks. The young girls seem to swoon over him.

Now.....am I the only that notices that Paula doesn't seem to have one original thought???? She says almost exactly what Randy says everytime!! She really annoys me for some reason. She tries to be too nice and not hurt anyones feelings. Maybe that is why I love Simon. He says it like it is.

 

[ShuisFan584]

I hope both Julia and Corey are in the bottom 3 because in my opinion, both of them should have been gone by now. I also don't like Kim C and have never seen anything great about her so I hope she's in the bottom 3, but I know she most likely won't be.

 

[Tinkbell]

Based on performance, I will say Julia, Corey and Trenyce. I really like Trenyce but she did not do too well last night. Country Rock just isn't her thing.