American Idol fans: Whos going to be in the Bottom 3?

[tinkerbee]

Corey, Ricky and Julia. Bye Bye Corey!!! I hope.

 

[Tess]

Julia, Corey, Carmen--although I don't totally discount Trenyce--she wasn't very good last night. Who knows, maybe 3rd time is the charm for Julia (although--to be honest, I thought she was better last night than the others mentioned above).

All I know is that when it came time to vote--I tried for 20 solid minutes hitting that redial and couldn't get through on either Josh or my choice, Clay! It's a sure bet they aren't outta' there!

 

[WDW Poly Princess]

Wow! I just checked the poll on AOL, here are the rankings according to the aol member votes (NOTE- This has nothing to do with the real rankings! Just an informal poll!)

1-Clay
2-Reuben
3-Josh
4-Kimberly C
5-Trenyce
6-Corey
7-Carmen
8-Kimberly L
9-Julia
10-Ricky


I can't believe Ricky is last! I didn't expect him to be in the top three or anything, but last??

 

[ead79]

If it were up to me, I would put Julia, Carmen, and Corey in the bottom three. Of course, it's not up to me.

 

[nancy679]

Did anyone notice that now that they are the finalists, no one except Corey mouths off to Simon? I think they are respectful of the comments, good or bad. Last night, COrey said something like "was that a back handed compliment?" about Simon, or another week he said, "glad you changed your shirt". It just totally turns me off.

 

[wvjules]

My bottom 3: Julia, Carmen and Kimberly L.

 

[wvjules]

Originally posted by LuvTigger
IDoes anyone else think that Simon has been kinder to Carmen than he would be with someone older?

I think he's nicer to her b/c she was his pick. He can't exaclty look like he made a mistake, now can he?

 

[pajamommy]

I agree with everyone who said Julia, Corey and Carmen. I really hope its Julia or Corey gone tonight, can't stand either of them. I wish Kimberly C. would go soon too!

 

[Poohbear123]

 

[Poohbear123]

WOW Kimberly C is the first in the bottom 3!

 

[wvjules]

"God Bless The USA" They did an awesome job.

 

[CJK]

Could someone PLEASE pass the tissue???????????
They don't call me Drama Queen for nothing!
What a show tonight!

 

[Planogirl]

I agree! This show isn't supposed to make me cry but it sure did. And I'm still stuck between Clay and Josh.

 

[GoofieRuthie]

I was actually shocked that Kim C made the bottom 3. I'm not fond of her, but I really thought everyone else was.

Anyone sobbing during the final God Bless America?????


and poor Kim C., I couldn't help but think of Tammy Faye Baker.

But thank goodness Julia is gone!!! I think she actually looked relieved that it was over.

 

[WDW Poly Princess]

Glad to see I'm not the only one who cried!

Re: the bottom 3.....


OH MY GOSH!!!

I was NOT expecting that! Julia was a given, but I can't believe that Kim C. and Ricky got fewer votes than Corey and Carmen!!!

And why is each person's best performance usually right after they are voted off? Julia actually didn't make me want to run and hide tonight!

 

[snoopy]

I think I need to boycott this show from here on out.

How is Corey still there? He had the weakest voice of all the finalists, BY FAR. While Julia is not my favorite, I thought she was a lot better than Corey, who sings off key more than he sings on key.

And Kim C. the bottom three? Uhhhh, I don't think so!

America has lost its collective mind.

 

[Robinrs]

I was pretty surprised last night, too...

Wow! Kim C in the bottom three. Maybe it'll take her inflated head down a notch!

Ricky instead of Corey? WhatsUPwidTHAT???

I think Julia was relieved. How horrible to be in the bottom three three times in a row. I'm sure the others think now that she's gone WHO will be the swan singer now?

 

[Minnie824]

I couldn't believe Kim was in the bottom 3 either. I thought this was her best performance. Also, we were thinking....seems kindof weird that they have the person who gets voted off sing the song that, really, they got voted off for singing. Oh, well. Yay to Julia being gone!

 

[Dodie]

Did you see Kimberly C. bawling her eyes out when she got sent back over to the risers with the others and during Julia's swan song? Those weren't tears over Julia getting booted off! Those were tears of disbelief that arrogant, cocky little Kimberly had been in the bottom two. I hope it brings her down a notch.

I was surprised at Ricky being there, but very relieved when he was "saved." He's talented and seems to be such a nice guy.

I agree that Julia seemed relieved that it was over.

If Corey doesn't go soon, I'm going to lose faith in this show pretty quickly.

I don't always think that the group performances sound that good - particularly since these folks aren't used to singing in a "choir" or group setting, but that rendition of "I'm Proud to Be an American/God Bless the USA" (the first time - not the filler at the end) was AWESOME! I thought it was great that they let Josh start it and sing the line about "starting over with just my children and my wife."

 

[suzannen]

I'm in disbelief - how did Corey not even make the bottom 3?? And, even if you don't like Kimberly C, to place her and Ricky there over Carmen? I really don't get it.