I have always wanted to stay at the Poly and now I'm planning on doing it

I was very disappointed when I read on another thread that the rooms smell musty and it is always crowded because of people coming to see the luau and wishes. I'm still planning on going to Poly anyway. I just wondered what you Poly fans think of what they said ?
I don't think it smells musty at all. I love the smell of the Poly!! As far as darkness (which you didn't mention, but usually goes along with that) - it's dark wood. The rooms themselves are not dark. The only place I find that needs more light is the bathroom. Someone suggested to me on here bringing a small light to plug in and that's what we're doing next time!!
As far as crowds, we have never found it to be an issue. 2 early May trips, and this year was late March (a fairly busy time). The GCH can get crowded around dinner time, especially if the weather turns bad and the Luau guests are in there, but it's not a problem to me. Have never found the beach to be too crowded. One of the things I love about the Poly is the separate longhouses, as opposed to one large hotel building. When we're at Chef Mickey's in the Contemporary I always wonder how LOUD it is in those rooms where the doors open right up into the main area (above CM's, etc.). At the Poly, even if the GCH is crowded, just a minute outside of it and aaaaahhhhh....peace and relaxation. The longhouse areas are usually very quiet. I find the Poly to be very peaceful, tropical and relaxing. I feel like I get a 2-for-1 vacation there - the fast-paced, fun, theme-park vacation and the slower, relaxing, beach/tropical vacation.
Hi! I apologize if this question has been asked/answered but I didn't see it.
I'm planning a trip for Oct 2012. It's my 1st trip since 1993 & will be the 1st trip for my husband & our sons. My husband gave me the go-ahead today to "splurge" & have us stay at the Polynesian. We're planning on Garden View. Can I ask my agent to request a certain house or floor and, if so, what do you suggest? I read through this thread & I'm sure you're the ones to ask
Thanks for any advice/suggestions/recommendations you're willing to share!
Everyone has different opinions on this for sure!! Someone above mentioned Fiji and for us - that was our least favorite (we only stayed 1 night and moved - 2nd floor, no balcony so that was part of it, but also Luau Cove noise).
For us, we just looooove Tokelau and are willing to move to get it if needed (only that once). I find it to be very quiet and it's centrally located to the pools, GCH and the TTC. The walk from the TTC to our room at night is one of my favorite things in all of Disney.
We also love first floor. It just helps us feel as if we have more space for the week. On our beach vacations, we always have a condo, so for the 4 of us to be in 1 room for the week...any extra space is good. Not sure how old your kids are, but on our first two trips, we had at least one napper. With the first floor, the napper(s) would sleep, and we'd sit outside. Could take turns going to CC's for a snack, taking a walk, etc. Now we have no more nappers, but the kids love to just step outside and "play" (look for lizards mostly), while I finish getting ready, etc.
In addition, we personally like the East Side of Tokelau (the west side faces the quiet pool, the east side faces Tahiti). Just a bit quieter and the patios open to a grassy area with the walk farther away. We've gotten it 2x. This past trip we were on the west side, but on the end, so basically a lagoon view (for GV price). That was GREAT! But we agreed we still preferred the other side, as the patio had landscaping around it, so harder to come and go, and the walkway was much closer.
So for us, our request is - First Floor, Tokelau, East Side.
But as I said, everyone likes different things. Definitely check out Tikiman's site to get good information on all the longhouses!
Off the wall question here but does anyone know if the "over the door shoe organizers" will fit over the door in the poly bathrooms? Will the door shut? anyone ever used these to organize all their bathroom stuff. Someone on the tips thread said they used them and they worked great. Thinking about trying it but I know sometimes it will keep the door from shutting all the way. Just wondering if anyone has tried this at the poly. Thanks so much for input.
We will be there September 17th....cant wait!
The door will not shut all the way with one of those on. Almost, but not quite. We brought one for the first time this year. We decided to just go with it, it was worth it for the great storage. Everyone knew if the door was "closed" (almost), it was in use. I have been trying to think of a way to "rig it" for next trip, so the door will close all the way, haven't come up with anything yet.