The reservation isn't made 12 months ahead of your use year, just 11-12 months ahead of the week itself, so reservation timing can vary depending on the Use Year and the Fixed Week. Only the fixed week reservation is made before the 11 month window by Disney, usually between 11 and 12 months ahead. If I want to use my points elsewhere, I can make a normal 11 or 7 month booking myself as well
If my reservation is made before Disney makes the fixed week reservation, then they cannot make it and I just use my points like a normal contract
- Ex. My Week 50 contract in my September use year is usually the second or so week of December. If in October, I make a 11 month reservation for something in September to tie up any amount of points out of that fixed week contract, there will be no Week 50 reservation made when December/January (12 and 11 months before week 50) comes around.
If Disney makes the fixed week reservation before I make any reservations or had borrowed any points (ie if the contract has full points for that year) then they will make the fixed week booking and I will have to cancel it with member services in order to use the points elsewhere
- Ex. My Week 39 contract in my September use year is usually the last week of September. If Disney books this a full 12 months ahead of time, they will book it at the end of September before I can book anything on October 1st for my use year to prevent it. I would contact member services and have them cancel the reservation and then I could use my points as a I want.
- In this case I would probably use some of my other points for the same resort to start a reservation for a day or two to guarantee I had a room I wanted, then cancel the fixed week and then extend the reservation I started. This way I do not risk losing a room I want while waiting on member services to cancel the reservation.
All in all after all my research I found that there were pretty much only positives when doing a fixed week, and I don't think I will ever buy any decent amount of direct points without a fixed week for a studio, duo, or maybe a 1br (if it's a hard to book 1br).
With a fixed week you can get:
- Guaranteed reservations at a time of your choice, usually a time and room combo that can be hard to book normally. And it can let you potentially plan trips years ahead for specific dates, instead of possibly at 11 months.
- Increased possible resale value, especially if it is a popular room and week
- A few weeks during the year that are actually LESS points for a fixed week than the average number of points they will cost to book each year due to abnormalities in the year the fixed week chart was made. Week 39 is one of those and why I booked it as it seemed like the only one in the Food/Wine Festival date range. (The year they made the chart Week 39 was mostly in September which is the lowest point season, but normally it goes a few days into October, which is a higher point season)
The only downsides I found were:
- It forces you to buy 10% extra points above your bare minimum. Which most people recommend doing anyway as you may not always travel in the same window or Disney may adjust the booking periods. You use the extra 10% of points when keeping the fixed week reservation as a fee for it, but if you cancel/skip the fixed week you never lose any points. It just adds flexibility in my mind, as you never have to actually use the fixed week
- Large contracts for 2brs or rooms with expensive views cannot be split into multiple contracts to increase resale value. A fixed week for 100-150 points shouldn't be hard to sell, but a contract for 300+ points with a fixed week may not resell better than 3 regular 100 point contracts due to smaller contracts selling for more per point as there are more potential buyers.