We were there last week and we loved it. Our reservation was at 10:00. Belle was in the front wearing her yellow dress. We bought the pictures that they took, of course, but you can take your own too and not buy the ones they offer. Breakfast was brought out. The cinnamon rolls were OK, not great, but everything else was really good. Eggs, potatoes, bacon, sausage were all very yummy and there was fruit as well. Plenty of food and it was hot and tasty, but nothing spectacular (like the french toast at CRT - yum!). The interaction was excellent. We saw Aurora, Snow, Mulan and Jasmine. Now, it was raining so I think some people didn't show up because the restaurant was not full, but the princesses spent a lot of time with dd.
So, I think that everyone has different experiences and you might just have to go and see for yourself, but I totally understand about not doing CRT and I think this is a good alternative. The 1900 Park Fare is EXCELLENT though if you decide not to do PSB.