I stayed there 2 years ago. We had the dining plan, and I think it was the least remarkable meal during my whole stay. Very plain. Nothing to get excited about. Could be better now, though, I don't know.
Personally, I would save the money and eat at the food court. You have to walk through the food court to get to Shutters anyway. If you're staying there, and you like a table service meal, it's okay, but I'd go somewhere else for a table service meal unless it's really inconvenient to do so.