I would say while there were parts that were really, really fun (the takeover of the ship, the fireworks, the random characters roaming the ship), I was left wanting a bit more. Some of the activities we went to were pretty ho-hum (Padawan Mind Challenge, I'm looking at you in particular), some were just OK (the character meet and greets were very much herding everyone through, WDW style) and there were parts of the day when I wanted a bit more to be planned.
An expert speaker would have been great (though since we missed two ports, maybe that impacted the lack of someone coming on board), or having Mickey and friends in Star Wars attire, or a few more events for all ages (our kid doesn't enjoy the kids' clubs so we couldn't do adult only activities).