I can finally breathe a sigh of relief as all of my travel arrangements have finally been completed!

We had everything booked for after the cruise but nothing booked before the cruise (airfare and hotel). We booked our return airfare months ago due to travel vouchers we had from the airline and we were going to take the train down (we live in Northern VA).
Well I wasn't really crazy about the 17+ hour trip but I refused to pay over $600 for one way airfare for 4. So I did the waiting game. As the cruise began to get closer and closer I was beginning to panic a little because we didn't have anything booked.
Well last night something magical happened. Airfare dropped! And dropped by over $300

Needless to say, we bought those tickets ASAP! We're flying in the day before (leaving in the afternoon after our son's soccer game) and staying at the Hyatt MCO. We're using
DCL transportation to get to the port.
After the cruise we're renting a car and heading to WDW/
MNSSHP and then flying home the next evening. We're so excited and DD is going to have the BEST 5th birthday ever!!! She turns 5 on the day we disembark and she'll spend her special day at Magic Kingdom
But I do have one question for you guys: right now we're staying at Star Island Resort after the cruise. We wanted to stay on Disney property at one of the value resorts. How are the rooms? Which value resort would you recommend? I can't wait til we cruise