I have 2 boys, ages 8 & 4, and I typically start with their wish lists and work backwards from there. Each boy typically gets 10 presents total, from Santa and us. I know this sounds like a lot but some of the presents are cheap little things, hot wheels, small action figures, etc. They typically get one "big" gift each.
Thankfully as an entire we family we dicided not to buy for extended family anymore a couple of years ago. My husband is the baby of 6 and I am an only child but have more cousins than I can count that we used to shop for. We now only buy for the grandparents and I do one of 2 things every year. I scrapbook a calender for the next year or I make a book from one of the many online photo shops with pictures of my boys throughout the year. Both have been a big hit. These gifts typically only cost me about $30 each.
Thankfully as an entire we family we dicided not to buy for extended family anymore a couple of years ago. My husband is the baby of 6 and I am an only child but have more cousins than I can count that we used to shop for. We now only buy for the grandparents and I do one of 2 things every year. I scrapbook a calender for the next year or I make a book from one of the many online photo shops with pictures of my boys throughout the year. Both have been a big hit. These gifts typically only cost me about $30 each.