would you rather live on acres of land or on a lake?

Which would you choose?

  • Living on a nice lake (with a dock and boat)

  • Living on about 10 acres to roam around on

  • Niether, those options aren't for me at all (please tell me what you would choose?)

  • I really can't decide, I like both


Results are only viewable after voting.
Well I pick land .

We live here in fla. and have 10 acres that our house is on and I love it.

There are only 12 houses out were we live and its nice and peaceful :thumbsup2

As far as a lake I have never been a water lover :lmao: Maybe cause seeing and going to the beach when I was younger so much justed burned me out.

Ron.
 
well, i live on 10 acres and i love it. but i do essentialy have 'waterfront property' since i have a huge pond that consumes a large portion of my 'back yard'. i love being able to look out on water and enjoy all the wildlife it attracts-i don't know that i would however enjoy living on a lake-if it was popular with sportsman or fishermen and the kind of 'wildlife' that might attract:rotfl2: i enjoy my peace and quiet and my property affords me that-if i had to contend with noise (and esp. drunken noise which was the norm at the popular lakes where we used to live) and littering (again a problem with those lakes-beer cans and the like) i don't think i would find it as enjoyable.

one thing that i would explore re. lakefront property is weather the home is part of a home owners association and what impact that has on ownership. we are in an hoa because of some special wrangling when this area was sold off and for the most part it's good but it can be a p.i.t.a.-and the potential for p.i.t.a homeowner's boards to get away with heck can be much greater if you live in an area where there are many absent homeowners who blindly give proxy's to people (we have as i imagine many lakefront areas have-people who only live here limited times during the year-so their views on a proposed decsion can be vastly different than people who live here year round and have to deal with very restricting rules on a daily basis-they think lowering the speed limit to a crawl of 15 mph is 'quaint'-it's not when you live with it 24/7:sad2: ).

explore the local newspapers to see if there are any contentious issues or strong restrictions/ordinances with the government or eco groups re a body of water. i know of water areas that were incredible recreation areas until some enviornmental group got heated up about the impact boating had on the indiginous species-not much enjoyment to a dock and a boat if a ban or highly restrictive laws are put into place regulating when/how it can be used. there are some lakefront communities that also have realy tight laws on construction-so if a person wants or needs to building or reconstruction it can be a bear to get permits-and then very restrictive on when the construction can take place (i recall watching one tv show where there was no construction permitted after like 4 in the afternoon nor on weekends or legal holidays-it put a major crimp in renos and drove the price up for contractors). there's some waterfront property in california that's sure changed from the beautiful place it was-largly because while it had no flooding issues, surrounding towns did-they won the right to re-route waterways that impacted the lake-it's now more of a mosquito sanctuary than a desirable locale

if the lake is popular with non owners look to the placement of the property vs. the public access areas. being too close can result in having people troop through your yard, block your driveway and cause you to have to constantly monitor your property/call the police or tow trucks. popular areas with the public also contribute to marked conjestion of surface roads around an area-so if you do your errands and shopping on the weekends it can mean dealing with all the traffic of the 'tourists' (i grew up in a touristy area-the roads were a mess on weekends).

evaluate the cost of homeowner's insurance, but also look at other expenses. having a dock means upkeep and maintainance (i have a friend whose dad retired quite well off doing dock maintainance for private home owners), does that body of water attract 'gods little creatures' that may necessitate more upkeep on the home and perhaps pest services.

like i said-i love my waterfront property-but it's MY water, i control who can and can't go into it (though an occasional neighbor's dog may not agree with that:) ).


check also to see how property taxes are done in the state. if you buy a place where people are doing major custom homes as the existing homeowners sell off and the value of those homes drive your tax basis it can become ungodly expensive. when we lived in california we were protected by a tax initiative that passed in the late 70's that kept our property taxes based on the price we paid when we originaly purchased our home-so even though the homes in our neighborhood jumped from $180,000 when they were built to $650,000 in 6 years-we retained reasonable taxes. before that passed-and in states that don't do that-if you own a 'normal' home but your neighbors sell off and custom 'mcmansions' start building up, your taxes get based on THEIR values (i know people in napa that before the initiative passed saw rural land skyrocket in value-their taxes quadrupled and they could'nt afford to keep their long term existing homes). it's great to have an increased value if you plan on selling, but if you plan on staying long term it eat up that potential profit quite a bit.
good luck in making your decision.
 
All good things to think about. I will ask about the insurance issue.

Right now we live on 2.5 acres and that is more than enough for me. DH is the one who wants land, BUT, he also knows that I have been pushing to move out of this area completely and back *home* to CA, so he is willing to pursue my dream of living on a lake if that will make this area more livable for me.

My kids are actually very good about not going anywhere I tell them not to and I would look for something with either a backyard area or a fenced in area where they could play. Most likely though, I would be out there with them or at least sitting on our huge patio/porch watching them.

We have a pool right now and they have never gone near it without permission. We have had a lot of talks about the dangers of going near water alone and not with a grown up.

I will look into past years' water levels. Most of the homes I have looked at are at least 50 ft. up from the shoreline though.

Dawn
 
How about 10 acres w/ a pond? The boys could still fish, rowboat, catch frogs, ice skate, etc, and you'd have privacy that sometimes being on a lake you can't get. just a thought...

good luck deciding!
 

Ten acres is a LOT of land to take care of. My parents live on a smaller acreage and they're actually looking to downsize now that they're retired.

I voted for lake because neither acreage nor lake guarantees you'll keep what you want, but lakes are less likely to go away. I know someone who bought acreage for the quiet and the absence of zoning laws. Well, now the neighbor on one side of her acreage is running some kind of very noisy shop. And there's nothing that can be done about it, because there are no zoning laws.
 
We had a situation like that, what made the difference for us was that with house with the land neighbors were not very close. We both wanted or child to have a neighborhood atmosphere where she could just walk down the block to her friends house, so we chose Lake and had a great time until we had to move out of the area. Also; a big piece of land will appreciate but believe me it will not appreciate as fast or as much as a waterfront property, especially if it is on a big lake. JMHO
 
I pick lake. I actually have lake front property. It is so nice to sit outside in the evenings and just mellow out infront of the lake. Plus I have a built in swimming pool anytime we need to cool off. haha
 
Definitely a lake. My parents have a lake house that we've been going to since I was little. If we could live there, we would. Just not enough jobs around there to accomodate our skills!

It's beautiful to wake up to in the morning...nothing like having your morning coffee and looking out at a peaceful lake. Watching the fisherman and the wildlife and all of that. It's fun when you want to have people over, or just hang out with the family. It's gorgeous at sundown and it's so soothing to listen to it at night. And it's fun getting to know the neighbors and all hanging out down by the water. It's also nice in the winter...watching the ice fisherman and skating on the lake when it freezes.

The downsides...there is work involved, although taking care of 10 acres is probably more work. Things like putting the dock in, taking it out and maybe raking the seaweed, depending on the lake. You will pay for that boat over and over. Initial cost, winterizing, insurance, gas, blah, blah, blah. They don't come cheap. And there is probably some kind of group that maintain things that go along with the lake that you may have to get involved in and pay money for. And you really have to watch your kids if they are little. Which is easy to do while spending the weekend at a lake house, but would be much harder in our day to day life. If they're a little older though, it's a great adventure for them. My brothers used to row the boat out to fish, catch turtles, etc. I would spend hours reading on the boat and stuff like that. And we all loved tubing and skiing.

All in all, a great experience. Definitely go with the lake! (Mmmmm...wishing it was summer right now!)
 
Well, we had an opportunity to have a pond and I really didn't want it. I wanted a speed boat for watershiing and such, not just a paddle or rowboat. Plus, around here, masquitoes are much worse on standing water than even on the lake from what I hear.

Sitting and looking over a pond for a sunset just doesn't do it for me. Unfortunately.

Dawn

How about 10 acres w/ a pond? The boys could still fish, rowboat, catch frogs, ice skate, etc, and you'd have privacy that sometimes being on a lake you can't get. just a thought...

good luck deciding!
 
I'd choose the acreage. My dream is to own a nice chunk of land, build a barn & raise dairy goats, among other livestock. I love me some wide open spaces, but can do without the water. Maybe because I've always lived within 15 minutes of ocean?
 
I would never sleep another wink if we lived on a lake. Christian would be drawn to the water like a magnet. Don't want to manage 10 acres, either. I think I'd rather invest in a good motorhome and see the USA
 
DH wouldn't get off enough time per year to make that even feesable. A motorhome would be way too much work for me too! :lmao: I would rather stick to hotels and driving.

Dawn

I would never sleep another wink if we lived on a lake. Christian would be drawn to the water like a magnet. Don't want to manage 10 acres, either. I think I'd rather invest in a good motorhome and see the USA
 
Well, DH better not have plans for any livestock! He works long hours and there is no way I am becoming a farmer! Besides, it is hard enough to find someone to watch the dogs when we go to Disney.

Dawn

I'd choose the acreage. My dream is to own a nice chunk of land, build a barn & raise dairy goats, among other livestock. I love me some wide open spaces, but can do without the water. Maybe because I've always lived within 15 minutes of ocean?
 
I think this is the key....DH wants no close neighbors! Never mind that he works in downtown Charlotte and is gone from 6am-6pm per day! He is the one who wants the land and yet I am the one stuck in the middle on nowhere all day! I am the city girl, he is the country boy. It doesn't mesh well.

We moved here from Los Angeles. Charlotte is small town enough for me without dragging me even further out to the country!

You know, I am really afraid that if we find lakefront I will never be open to moving if it will mean we can't live on a lake again! :goodvibes Like I said, this has been a dream of mine since I was a little girl.

Dawn

We had a situation like that, what made the difference for us was that with house with the land neighbors were not very close. We both wanted or child to have a neighborhood atmosphere where she could just walk down the block to her friends house, so we chose Lake and had a great time until we had to move out of the area. Also; a big piece of land will appreciate but believe me it will not appreciate as fast or as much as a waterfront property, especially if it is on a big lake. JMHO
 
We choose the land when we built our house several years ago. There's a lake community not far from us that we could have moved into, but, eh. Plus, as others have mentioned, property values go through the roof for lake front. Our 14 acres costs less than some of the lake front properties for taxes.
 
I'd choose acres of land over a lake any day. While the view of a lake is nice, I live in the south, which equals lots of snakes and mosquitos when you throw in water.
 
To get away from living so close to neighbors and having room to roam. The kids would also love the extra room for race tracks and such. Most importantly I'm a worry wart and would worry about my kids drowning in the lake. I wouldn't be able to sleep easy until they were all in their teens.
 
You didn't specify how much land was with the lakefront lot -- but here goes my 2 cents anyway.


My neighborhood has 4 lakes I have 2.5 acres with my house. We opted not for lake front property (we are about a 10 minute walk to 2 of the lakes from my house). These are my reasons for no lakefront and why we chose not to build on the lake:

1. kids (DD was 2 at the time) -- while we have a pool, I can control the pool (gate) -- I can't control the lake.

2. SNAKES SNAKES SNAKES

3. MOSQUITOES MOSQUITOES MOSQUITOES

Now for the land. If it was 10 acres that I would have to bushhog -- no way. 10 acres mostly wooded that I don't have to mow -- yes.
 
We are on 25 acres, and I don't feel it is enough most times! Especially when the neighbors hold their nightly parties in the summer, or ride around on their snowmobiles in the winter! Water is nice, but solitude is priceless!
 
we moved from california as well-and to 10 acres (although we have ponds eating up some of it). 10 acres depending on what type of land it is-and how you want it to look will determine much of how much upkeep you have to do.

we looked at places that were stunningly landscaped-but i reccognized the time and expense of maintaining it. we wanted something that we could work with but the bulk of which we could retain in a much more natural manner. to that end we purchased property that provides us the opportunity to landscape around the house but has a much more forest like setting on the rest of the property (dawnm-ours would remind you of areas of california because of all the pine trees with the snowy mountains views off our back deck:love: ). so our upkeep is/will be the formal landscaping around the home with just general brush abatement on the rest of the property.

it is different living futher away from neighbors-but we've found that we know our neighbors much better than when we lived in a traditional neighborhood. people watch out for one another (when we had a massive snow dump neighbors were checking in with one another to ensure people without power had heat sources, we loaned a spare hand powered coffee grinder to our caffeine addicted neighbor to facilitate his 'needs':laughing: , and we awoke one morning to find several neighbors out with snow moving equipment clearing everyones entrances to their driveways:thumbsup2 ). it's a different kind of community feeling-but very much like what i remember as kid (when the neighborhoods were filled with sahm's who knew each other and all watched out for each other's kids-not like now with so many massive commuter parents and latch key kids:guilty: ).

who knows dawnm-you could have the same flukey experience we did. moved from california, did'nt know a soul-moved into our remote country home-to find out that the neighbors on the 2 adjacent 10 acre parcels-are BOTH from our california home town and moved here for the same reason:rotfl2: what are the odds?
 





New Posts










Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top