Woman fired after donating kidney to her boss

minniecarousel

Chris Isaak fan
Joined
Jul 13, 2000
Messages
13,925
Yikes! woman donates kidney so that her boss can get bumped up the donor list and she ends up firing her. (the intent was to donate directly to the boss, but they weren't a match). I hope she sues and gets millions - what's the price of a kidney in this country?


"A New York Long Island woman said she was fired after she donated a kidney to help save the life of her boss.

Debbie Stevens, a 47-year-old divorced mother of two, filed a formal complaint with the New York State Human Rights Commission last Friday, claiming her boss used her for her organ then fired her "after the woman got what she wanted." Stevens' boss, 61-year-old Jackie Brucia, is one of the West Islip controllers for Atlantic Automotive Group, a billion-dollar dealership operator. Brucia hired Stevens in January 2009 as an assistant.

"She just started treating me horribly, viciously, inhumanly after the surgery," Stevens told ABCNews.com. "It was almost like she hired me just to get my kidney." Although Stevens turned out to be less than a perfect kidney match for Brucia, Stevens donated her organ to an out-of-state stranger so that Brucia could move up on the organ donor list.

Stevens left the company in June 2010 to move to Florida. She returned to New York in September to visit her daughter, and decided to stop in at the dealership, according to the complaint. It was during this visit that Brucia told Stevens of her need for a kidney transplant.

"She said she had a possible donor, a friend or something," Stevens said. "But I told her if anything happened that I'd be willing to donate my kidney. She kind of jokingly replied, 'You never know, I may have to take you up on that one day.'"

A few months later, Stevens moved back to Long Island and asked Brucia if she had any job openings. Brucia hired her within weeks.

Then, in January 2011, Stevens said her boss called her into her office and asked if she was serious about donating her kidney.

"I said, 'Yeah, sure. This isn't a joking matter,'" Stevens said. "I did not do it for job security. I didn't do it to get a raise. I did it because it's who I am.

"I didn't want her to die," Stevens said.

When tests revealed that Stevens was not the best match, doctors agreed to let her give her kidney to someone in Missouri, which gave Brucia a higher place on the organ donor list.

Stevens underwent surgery on Aug. 10, 2011. She said doctors hit a nerve in her leg, causing her discomfort and digestive problems.

She returned to work four weeks later, and said that's when the problems began.

"I don't have words strong enough or large enough to describe her treatment of me," Stevens said. "Screaming at me about things I never did, carrying on to the point where she wouldn't even let me leave my desk. It was constant, constant screaming."

Stevens said she was demoted and moved to a car dealership 50 miles from her home. She said the mental stress got even worse, with her supervisor calling her an "actress."

"It got so bad that I'd start to tear up at times," Stevens said.

After consulting a psychiatrist for her mental stress, Stevens' hired attorneys who sent a letter to Atlantic Automotive Group.

Stevens was fired within a week.

When reached by ABC News, AAG referred all calls about the case to Jackie Brucia, Stevens' supervisor, who could not be reached for comment, at either the car dealership or her home. It is not known whether Brucia has legal representation at this time.

Stevens' attorney, civil rights lawyer Lenard Leeds, said he planned to file a discrimination lawsuit against AAG, and would likely seek millions of dollars in compensation.

"Our ultimate goal is to bring this before federal court," Leeds said. "We're alleging they discriminated against her for her disability and they retaliated against her when she complained about the harassment."

Leeds said the damages sought will be for Stevens' lost pay, psychological and physical well being.

"I have no comment on her. I'm just going walk ahead and live my life," Stevens said."
 
That's gratitude for ya. Thanks for donating a kidney so I could move up on the list. YOU'RE FIRED!!!!!
 
That whole situation stinks. I don't blame the donor for being angry. It does look like she was duped. Poor lady!
 
I saw the donor on TV yesterday with her attorney. She seemed somewhat passive to me. Of course, her lawyer has probably limited what she should say.

On thing that occurred to me is that maybe the supervisor didn't want to be accused of favoritism toward the donor, so she was harder on her as a result.

It will be interesting to watch what happens.
 
Unbelievable. I also read that her boss screamed at her for taking 3 extra days off for her recovery. DH and I participated in a paired exchange. He was not a match for me, so his kidney was sent to CA, while mine came from PA. He was fortunate to be a candidate for laparoscopic removal, but it is still a more difficult recovery for the donor than the recipient, even without any complications, which it sounds like the donor had.
 
Just like incidents I've heard on the DIS where someone crying medical hardship, poverty, etc. People come out to help and find out it was a scam. :sad2::sad2: Karma has a way of hitting back. Wouldn't want to be the boss if she's still waiting for a kidney. :rolleyes:
 
I have never sued a person in my life. This is one l hope the donor sues and wins big time. Can we say Horrible Bosses.:scared1:
 
Unbelievable. I also read that her boss screamed at her for taking 3 extra days off for her recovery. DH and I participated in a paired exchange. He was not a match for me, so his kidney was sent to CA, while mine came from PA. He was fortunate to be a candidate for laparoscopic removal, but it is still a more difficult recovery for the donor than the recipient, even without any complications, which it sounds like the donor had.

My friend was the donor to her dad, and she had a heck of a recovery bc basically you are taking a healthy person and causing trauma to their body, whereas the reciepient is usually so sick, that the new kidney makes them feel much better much sooner.

That poor donor!
 
What a horrible and sordid little tale. Shame on that employer, she is a real Queen B! I hope that her former assistant will be OK, both physically and financially. I hope that she wins her law suit or an amicable settlement out of court be reached.














~~ I love you Phil and you will forever be with me! Forever my very best and most special friend! I love you to no end. ~~
 
No good dead goes unpunished. Bet the boss was ticked that she didn't get the kidney and someone else did so she took it out on her. Way to repay someone for trying to save your life.

Hope the donor/employee gets a nice settlement out of this. I think they are going to have a tough time fighting this, if it went down the way the article is stating it did.
 
Of course this has to be in my neck of the woods (well, at least 20 minutes away) :sad2: Sheesh, I can't believe that happened. I've never been to Atlantic Auto and after this, I never will. The nerve of some people. I hope she wins her case.
 
There has to be more to this. This story is just so...odd. For what reason, exactly, are they suing? While the article makes the boss sound ungrateful and mean it did not clearly delineate what law(s) she broke. Can someone fill me in?
 
Sounds like they are suing for wrongful termination. She basically is claiming she was treated unfairly/harassed at work and then when she complained about it, she got fired. At least that's how I read it.
 
The article mentions a disability but doesn't say what the disability is. Was it the kidney surgery or was it stress?

While on the surface it sounds bad, I would need to see all the details before declaring the company wrong.
 












Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE







New Posts



DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top