I'm a pretty pixie-dust kind of guy - and we bought into DVC, so we'll be staying at WDW until we shuffle off to the Great Toon Town in the Sky - but I do appreciate reasonable and rational negative posts. Of course, I will always make up my own mind, but much like restaurant reviews, movie / stage reviews, and Consumer-reports type information, I like to hear other people's opinions, even if they are negative - it helps with expectation management. It's all grist for the mill-stone of my mind - yes, that means my head is full of rocks!
What I don't like is unthinking blanket statements about something; it's even worse if the opiner hasn't even experienced the item in question yet.