This is exactly what I was going to say. You beat me to it!!!Gaiusrex said:3 words. Location, location, location. It is the only resort that allows you to walk to the MK. Several rooms in the tower have a view of the MK.

lark said:You also have to understand the nostalgia factor. Many people who stayed there and loved it as kids (or, even more significantly, that couldn't afford to stay there as kids but saw it and were awe-struck by it) are now adults with disposable income.
We're going next year with my 42 year old BIL, who hasn't been to WDW since he was 14, although has done DL many times since. He really, really wants to stay the the Contemporary. To him staying there is the epitome of the Disney experience. My dh to an extent felt the same way although he was more of a Poly guy. To some there is just something about the original resorts. 
Tee hee hee--just kidding. The Contemporary is one of those things with a face only a mother could love.

(sigh)... we stayed at CR 5/2005 and while it was a nice, big room and nice, big resort, we simply didn't fall in love with it like we did AKL. HOWEVER, for the fall dining special, as a single mom with 4 under 12 including one child under 3, I KNEW that the monorail it had to be. I could picture trying to get from EP or MK on a crowded bus and having to stand with my son in my arms, my 7 year old DD ready to kill my 12 year old DD and my 13 year old DD walking away from us all!!
I REALLY wanted WL and hopefully I can work out something with a DVC owner I know, but with wanting to go to MNSSHP & EP F&W Fest, the monorail is the only way to keep my sanity. Plus..
my son loves trains!
Here I go again, having to book CR for the sake of my family. The things we do for our children! 
phantom728 said:We stayed at CR in 2002 because SOG was closed for renovations. We got the CR room for the SOG rate (which was cheaper than value resorts due to military rank tier) and would never pay full price for the rooms we were in. We were on the first floor and every morning were awoken by the ducks who came looking for food and then would s#@! on our patio.


goofy4tink said:Correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't the CR actually cheaper than most of the other deluxes? It is more expensive than WL and AKL, but it is, or at least it was, cheaper than either GF or Polynesian.
lark said:Well, it depends. Yes, a standard garden wing room at the contemporary is less expensive than the cheapest rooms at the other five major deluxes, but a little more expensive than the two more intermediate deluxes. The difference between the garden view in the wings at the CR is pretty much right on par with the least expensive rooms at the other deluxes -- $10 or $15 less than the Poly, BWI, BC/YC -- except for the GF.
I think there's a considerable difference in terms of deluxe feel between the other two monorail resorts or the BC/BY/BWI and the contemporary wings. Don't get me wrong, I think the wings are probably, dollar for dollar, the best value in disney, but the real apples to apples comparison for the CR to other resorts is the tower, and that's pretty much right on par with the other major resorts, right down to the concierge, except for the GF main building. The LV class at the GF and the Poly are a little more expensive than the tower MK view, but it's pretty close, and the tower bay side is more expensive than the garden rooms at the other deluxes.