The Yachtsman is a must do for me on every trip. Our son's (20 and 24) also love it and everyone that I have recommended it to also loves it, but there are a lot of others who don't. If you do a search on the boards you will find many differing opinions. I've always had great service, great food and a good time. I'm at WDW about 3 times each year and I always go there. The Yachtsman is expensive, for the dining plan it is a 2ts credit meal (as compared to Le Cellier which is a 1 ts credit meal), but well worth it. I have the DDE card and receive a 20% discount so that works well (DVC is a 10% discount). The dress for the Yachtsman is business casual. I enjoy having a window table to watch the people go by. The Crews Cup lounge is a great place to hang out waiting for your ADR to come up. After dinner a walk around the boardwalk is a great way to end the day. Have fun.